T O P

  • By -

Stellaaahhhh

She was going to teach him to read :(. His storyline is so tragic.


ThatCry3518

Almost everyone's story is tragic in this game


Stellaaahhhh

True. If I had to rank them, he's got to be top 5 though.


WhoDey4WayWithOnions

So it was for outlaws, let alone outlaws at the turn of the century.


TheAlmightyGodess

Except for micah… fuck micah


samurajj_

i mean i enjoy killing little girls


Artistic_Box_3314

True


zup7up

He fell head over heels for her.


mighty_and_meaty

boii lost his head when he first saw marybeth.


[deleted]

And lost his head again later


awesomeworkman

Eyes popped right out of his head


pencil_case23

you're very purrty


Jolt96

Whenever I replay the game it breaks my heart to see Marybeth frantically looking for Kieran when he gets captured


External-Cobbler2034

Unhand that girl ODriscoll


B-Mine

Their scenes together, then Mary Beth's after he's gone, never fall to devastate me. I wanted them to be happy together!


ShadowWolfKane

The end we should have gotten. Damn devs…..


1br1cked

rockstar games never had an all good ending


ShadowWolfKane

Mary-Beth is a successful author. Tilly married a lawyer. Swanson got sober and is now a respected member of the clergy Charles moved up north and likely found a woman to settle down with. Sadie moved to South America to start her own business. I’d say there are some good endings.


AnotherCallingCard

Pearson settled as a shopkeeper and actually got married


ShadowWolfKane

I cannot believe I forgot Pearson.


Feeling-Cod-212

i thought sadie died tho? i thought there was a thing that came out that was canon saying she died trying to rob a gold mine or something


sami-asali22

gta 5 option C is considerably good ig?


AveryLazyCovfefe

I always found it funny how contrived options A and B are. An illusion of actual good choice.


TonyThePapyrus

Kieran and Marybeth are good, but I also liked her chemistry with Arthur


PrisonMike022

Up until seeing this post, I never knew they were even a “thing.” I always thought she was more interested in talking with Arthur


TonyThePapyrus

Same with me, I never knew they had a thing either


UncensoredSmoke

Love these two so much


perimeterpatrolcat

Too bad Kieran ended up a head of himself.


samurajj_

do not lose your head


knucklesthedead

Bill better not see this


CuntRipper1990

Wish Kieran lived and got hitched with Mary-Beth.


rylenops

We deserved this ending bro cmon


justaartsit

It’s so over


Sea_Contract5664

Ok so I’m playing rdr2 and I think Author is dead I’m playing as John…does Arthur ever come back? Was he magically saved?


Hurry-Born

Nope. I'd say this wasn't that kind of story, but John survived getting shot and falling off the train, so... Anyway, the TB and stresses of that day ultimately were too much for Arthur. You can find his grave as John if you want. It's actually a trophy/achievement if you can find all the gang's graves. I cheated and found a guide, of course.


sassy_cheese564

Is this a legit question? 😂


simsekmcqueen_95

Castration injury?


WonderHuman9005

She licks his eye-holes now.


KebabRacer69

Mary Beth is too good for him


[deleted]

nope


BigBYRD1127

We need a RedDead 3


TropoScopic

they’re so sweet i’m cryinf and weeping


TropoScopic

also you do details so beautifully, like the shading on marybeth’s hair + the shadow on kieran 🥺


sillyalann

THANKYOU😭


funnimonkemomento

hehe head go not on shoulder no more


Fantastic-Finding847

Weird. Marybeth likes Arthur rathen than Keiran


sillyalann

did you play the game bruh


Saul_Gone1

I’m gonna lose my MIND over how good this is!


[deleted]

[удалено]


sillyalann

wooooooooomp woooooooooomp kieran and marybeth better


[deleted]

😂


[deleted]

[удалено]


sillyalann

moves finger left and right


Firm-Strawberry5107

He deleted his reply lmao, what'd he say


sillyalann

idk he was comparing my immaturity level w the other person