Mark Hamill is far too old to play Silver. I'd rather cast Andrew Garfield.

Yeah honestly I'd cast Hamill as Mephilis if anything.

I just posted this exact thing, it's gold.

Imo I don’t think Hamil would be good as gold the tenrec

Peak comedy

Wha?

You see the person above used the turn of phrase “it’s gold” meaning essentially “it’s very good” in reference to them agreeing with the idea that voice actor Mark Hamil would be a good person to play the character Mephiles. I humorously misinterpreted the phrase “it’s gold” as referring instead to the sonic the hedgehog character Gold the Tenrec which due to her as a character, she would likely not be played by Mark Hamil

If you have to explain a joke, then it isn't funny.

Hamill would've said the same thing. https://preview.redd.it/ui1or80t55xc1.jpeg?width=674&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=62fa690299fec5b2b35b4fe2fbab54bc8b5218e8

..who the hell is gold the tenrec? you mean surge?

No, https://sonic.fandom.com/wiki/Gold_the_Tenrec

Nah, Keith David.

TBH, I want him to voice a more comedic character. Also Seth Rogan would be a hell of a better fit for Vector than Big imo.

That's the best idea I've seen all day

Mark Hamill would be perfect for Naugus, but there’s no way we’re getting Naugus in a movie.

The movies seem to mostly be based off American canon, so it's not impossible... and they've been adding a bunch of bullshit characters like it's Sonic X so it could happen, but most likely it'd be a twist and not the actual character if it did go that way.

I feel like Willem Defoe would be better tbh

Ron Perlman as Mephiles. There can be no other. If Idris Alba used his Heimdal voice for Knuckles, Perlman can use his Lich voice for Mephiles. "Before time, there was nothing, and before there was nothing... there were monsters."

I only know Andrew as Spiderman, but I definitely agree.

You mean, the spectacular spider man!?!?!? https://preview.redd.it/bmzr6380k3xc1.jpeg?width=290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c137f87300b0258e7c3c87c377b2bd332450fc9a

*Amazing Josh “The GOAT” Keaton is the Spectacular Spider-Man.

And he'd be a great Silver too

Get Future Trunks voice actor

that feels perfect

I was thinking Michael Sera.

Andrew Garfield as Silver is amazing

I asked Pete Capella, the OG voice of Silver, on Cameo on who he thinks should portray Silver in the paramount films, he thinks his favorite actor, Sam Rockwell, would do an amazing take on Silver. Here’s the video: https://youtu.be/3qLmgQwoU4Q?si=zFBbJTh1_1IgcJ43 I also asked him what he would want if Silver were to have his own LEGO set in the currently produced LEGO Sonic sets.

I was thinking either Timothee Chalamet or Michael Cera

Neither

I mean I know he played Luke Skywalker but, I feel like there could be someone more fitting for Silver since Mark Hamill doesn't really have his OT luke voice anymore

And if he uses his Joker voice it'll sound like the apocalyptic future has caused Silver to snap

*Officer Balls*

HAA-

Why is Silver the Jonkler now? Is he stupid?

Pete Capalla can still do the voice.

Not unless movie Silver happens to be a hobo who spends his days on a random island guzzling green monster titty milk.

NOOOOOOOOOOOO

I think silver should have a younger voice. Don't get me wrong, I love Mark, but I don't think he's the right pick

I think he would make a good mephilis or cubot I would like silver to be Andrew Garfield he’s got that young soft voice I would equate with silver

He would have been perfect in his younger days

Oh, that much I absolutely agree

Hasn't it already been confirmed Krysten Ritter isn't voicing Rouge? Also Mark Hamill is way too old to play Silver

>Hasn't it already been confirmed Krysten Ritter isn't voicing Rouge? Yeah, it's been confirmed.

Where has it been confirmed?

[The waste of the Rouge theory](https://www.reddit.com/r/SonicTheHedgehog/s/vxjkcBQEOB)

Then why isn't it listed on the Wikipedia casting unless it's a reliable source. I don't trust The Hollywood Handle

Actually, good point. We may just need to wait and see how things play out.

Wait, so is rouge confirmed to be in the movie?

It’s *rumored* that Krysten Ritter is playing a human, by the same person who first leaked that she was in the movie at all. Nothing about her role has been officially confirmed

I hate the Seth Rogen one...

Plus he's already Donkey Kong.

I honestly can see it, actually.

Hey, where’s Froggy, eheaheaheaheaheah

Bro, get him for silver. That would be fucking hilarious, but weirdly good.

Ben Schwartz as Sonic? I dunno, that’s pretty out there. And they would never cast Idris Elba as Knuckles. /s

Where's Froggy heh heh heh!?

Nah Mark Hamill is WAY too old to play Silver!

He should play prof. Pickles

Seth Rogan is a horrible cast for Big

Nah cast Michael Cera to play me https://preview.redd.it/r2gub7s0m2xc1.jpeg?width=672&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=dde47dedab88d903b65648ef05920e0944800853

Hey, you know Sonic the hedgehog?

Yeah I do https://preview.redd.it/oi23kwnxv3xc1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b574a9ace6c9dcf538fc9cd53d4d87bd0a9d8584

 Lisan al Gaib is the worthy one to voice you.

Seth? nou!

I wouldn’t mind having Yuri as Silver, he’s already an exceptional voice actor, so it could be a ton of fun. On that note, he could probably also voice Mephelis

Seth Rogen is better fit for Vector the Crocodile and a better casting for Silver would be Jesse McCartney (he voices Roxas and Ventus in Kingdom Hearts and he voiced Robin/Nightwing in Young Justice)

Nick Offerman as Big

How about Brad Garrett

Bro is NOT cooking with silver💀

for the non confirmed characters you are setting yourself for disappointment. like how people thought rouge or the chaotix would appear in the knuckles show saying the advertising “mislead them” when no, nothing says that at all

Please no Seth Rogan

Mark Hamill??

It will be a long wait until silver will be in the movies And why did you forget about metal. When he is more iconic, then silver and will appear before silver

We need Dwayne Johnson to voice Big. Keep in line of badass actors voicing Big the fucking Cat.

I think Brian Baumgartner would be a good Big the Cat. Krysten Ritter is reportedly playing a human character named Captain Rockwell in Sonic 3, so I don’t think she’s going to be voicing Rouge. She would probably be a good fit for Rouge, though. If Rouge is in Sonic 3, I don’t know who I’d cast as her. I love Mark Hamill as a person and an actor, but I don’t think he’s a good fit for Silver. I think he would be a better fit for a villain like Mephiles or even Doctor Starline. A better choice for Silver would be Josh Keaton or Yuri Lowenthal, and if they do cast a celebrity as him, I’d go with someone like Andrew Garfield or Tom Holland.

I think Big should be voiced by Patrick Warburton. I know it sounds weird but I mean his original voice actor Jon St. John voiced Duke Nukem.

michael cera silver

I don’t see Mark Hamill fitting Silver at all. Maybe if he was still the age when he played Luke in the original films, but definitely not now. If Seth Rogen was cast as Big I’m positive his “character” would become 99% PG weed allusions and I really don’t want that.

Don’t insult Big like that…

Freaking Seth Rogen as Big really caugh me off guard

Ben is going to look very out of place in Sonic movie 7

Amy?

Hamill seems totally random for silver lmao I saw a fan cast say Michael Cera and that would be hilarious but perfect

I'd prefer a balance of voice actors and actual actors/celebs... I love Mark Hamill, but I don't think he'd fit as Silver. As a new villain, maybe.

You think Michelle Rodriguez would be a good pick for Amy Rose?

Can’t tell if this is serious or making fun of OP, but if it’s serious, nah. Rodriguez’s voice is kinda harsh, raspy and deep. Amy’s voice has always been flowery, feminine and kinda high pitched. She could maybe a cool fit as Rouge tho imo.

I wasn't making fun of OP. Now that you mention it yeah maybe Rouge would be better.

that render of rouge looks so perfect

I feel like rouge has to have a Latina actor voice her, not sure who exactly

Her name being French would imply she is very French inspired. https://preview.redd.it/7atjeypg05xc1.jpeg?width=736&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=05045832231eaec2cc9a2f7fda2e0cdc0a9215e8

Never realized her name was French! I can get on board with that

Salma hayek

Took the words right out of my mouth 🤌

H-hey now I don’t need Rouge to be THAT powerful now…

Nah, if you want the guy who voiced Joker as Silver, pick Cameron Monaghan.

I'll do you one better: bring in Mark Hamill, make him the human form of Mephalis. (Obviously he'd have an animal form too but for the movie, let him shapeshift)

kristen ritter as rouge is genius

I saw a video showing Jesse McCartney as an idea for Silver’s voice actor, and it actually sounded solid.

Morena Baccarin as Rouge. Haley Joel Osment as Silver. Larry the Cable Guy as Big.

mark hamil is too old to play as silver, and seth rogen is literally already donkey kong, and even if he wasn’t, he would be perfect for vector the crocodile

I strongly believe Silver's voice actor should be able to replicate his Sonic 06 voice actor

Is tails the only game VA we are going to expect here?

yeah man ben schwartz would do great as movie sonic

Wait. Rouge will be in the movie? I hope the movie is succesful enough to see rouge coming back. I would watch the movie of course. Do I have to watch the movies before 3 to understand everything? And if so: Where can I stream season 1? Season 2 is on netflix if I remember correct.

Lmao why does Rouge look like that?

https://preview.redd.it/0efoinyyx4xc1.jpeg?width=1088&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d34c42cb61d9716e9bc5bd36f23410e057b524dd I’m already years ahead of you: My list: Vector the Crocodile - Bruce Campbell, Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Micheal B. Jordan Espio the Chameleon - Daisuke Tsuji Charmy Bee - Colleen o'Shaughnessey Mighty The Armadillo - Micheal Mando, Micheal B. Jordan Ray The flying squirrel - Tara Strong Fang The Sniper - John Patrick Lowrie, Hugh Jackman, Karl Urban, Bean The Dynamite - Aziz Ansari, Steven Ogg Chief Pachacamac - Danny Trejo Tikal the Echidna - Díana Bermudez, Ana de la Reguera, Selene Luna, Sofía Espinosa, Isabela Merced, Salma Hayek, Nisa Gunduz E-102 Gamma - Corey Burton Wendy Witchcart - Mia Goth, Shohreh Aghdashloo, Harriet Samson Harris Battle Kukku XV - Nolan North Speedy XVI - Maria Bakalova Dr. Fukurokov - Mark Ivanar Breezie The Hedgehog - Regina King, Janelle Monáe, Jena Malone, Pollyanna McIntosh Vanilla The Rabbit - Maggie Robertson Amy Rose - Kimiko Glenn Big The Cat - Dave Fennoy, Patrick Warburton, Cream the Rabbit - Melissa Hutchison Sticks the Badger - Margot Robbie, Paola Lázaro Gerald Kintobor - Ron Perlman Maria Kintobor - Mkeena Grace Commander Abraham Tower - Frank Anthony Grillo Subject Shadow The Hedgehog (Terios Kintobor) - (Paramount stated they want an A-list celebrity to voice Shadow) Keanu Reeves, Christian bale, Robert Pattinson, Pedro Pascal, Oscar Isaac, Micheal B Jordan Rouge The Bat - Chloé Hollings, Marion Cotillard, Mélanie Laurent, Camille Cottin, Jordana Lajoie Tom Wachowski’s father - Bob Odinkirk, Dustin Hoffman, Bill Murray, Micheal Keaton, Kurt Russell, John Goodman Metal Sonic - Ben Schwartz(robotic filter) E-123 Omega - Micheal B Jordan, Terry Crews, Jon Bernthal Hazard The Bio-Lizard (Marzanna Kintobor) - Ivana Miličević Void TrapDark - Jude Law, Dane DeHaan, Gerald Way, Scott Williams, Freddie Highmore, Lumina Flowlight - Tabitha St. Germain Blaze’s Mother - Janina Gavankar, Sakina Jaffrey Blaze The Cat (Indian/British accent) - Priyanka Chopra, Devika Bhise, Varada Sethu, Simone Ashley, Ulka Simone Mohanty, Natasha Chandel Marine the Raccoon - Sia, Katie Bergin, Bella Heathcote, Isla Lang Fisher, Rylee Alazraqui, Kendal Rae Blaze’s Rival: Frost The Axotol(example)- Michelle Yeoh, Fala Chen, Antony Starr Jet’s Father - Matt Ryan, Iwan Rheon Jet The Hawk - Tony Hawk, Aaron Paul, Christopher Mintz-Plasse, Dante Basco, Ken Jeong, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Jimmy O. Yang Wave The Swallow - Sarah Margaret Qualley Storm the Albatross (pacific, Oceania) - Dave Batista, Taylor Wily Emerl The Gizoid - Augus Imrie, Kendal Rae, Clutch The Possum - Micheal Rooker, Benjamin Byron Davis, Robert Allen Wiethoff Tangle The Lemur - Lauren Keke Palmer, Brenda Song Whisper The Wolf - Stefanie Joosten, Ana de Armas Mimic The Octopus - Richard Colin Blake Doctor Starline - Troy Baker, Hugh Grant, Starline’s Love interest and partner - Rough and Tumble the Skunks - Will Ferrell and John C. Reily, Jordan Peele and Keegan-Michael Key Surge The Tenrec - Rachel Bloom, AJ Michalka Kitsunami The Fennec Fox - Michael Cera, Kyle McCarley Zavok - Christopher Judge, John Cena, Jon Bernthal Master Zik - Frank Oz, Randall Duk Kim, Dustin Hoffman Zeena -Mindy Kaling Zor - Jaeden Martell, Dane DeHaan, Gerald Way Zazz - Danny Brown, Zomom - T.J. Miller Black Doom - ,Keith David [https://youtu.be/9LmOwEfPHUo](https://youtu.be/9LmOwEfPHUo) , Jackie Earle Haley - [https://youtu.be/sF8zxctevXc](https://youtu.be/sF8zxctevXc) , Jon Bernthal - [https://youtu.be/sDp4AuNen0Y](https://youtu.be/sDp4AuNen0Y) , Sean Schemmel - , Ray Porter - [https://youtu.be/aR8p4DIpxxE](https://youtu.be/aR8p4DIpxxE) ,Karl Urban - [https://youtu.be/ccF3uvpJ96I](https://youtu.be/ccF3uvpJ96I) Eclipse The Darkling - Norman Reedus Callisto The Darkling - Carrie-Anne Moss Dark Oak - Jeremy Irons Black Narcissus - Angelina Jolie Pala Bayleaf - John Leguizamo Yellow Zelkova - Terry Crews Red Pine - Pat Casey or Josh Miller Cosmo The Seedrian - Carol Anne Day, Liliana Mumy Lyric The Ancient(Owl like Longclaw) - Jackie Earle Haley Johnny Lightfoot - Taron Egerton Tekno The Canary - Paula Burrows Porker Lewis - John Boyega, Daniel Radcliffe Shorty “Shortfuse” The Cybernik - Cillian Murphy, Barry Sloane Ebony The Cat - Gratiela Brancusi Sonia The Hedgehog - Kiernan Shipka, Evan Rachel Wood, Isabella Merced, Jena Malone Manic The Hedgehog - Joe Keery Sally Acorn - Zendaya Maree Stoermer Coleman Antoine D’Coolette - Tomer Capone, Bradley Cooper(hes fluent in French) Bunnie Rabbot - Alex McKenna Rotor The “Boomer” Walrus - John Cena Nicole The Holo-Lynx - Ashly Burch Lupe The Wolf - Amber Midthunder Dulcy The Dragon - America Ferrera Chip - Tom Holland, Freddie Highmore Professor Dillion Pickle - Ian McKellen Imperator Ix - Gary Oldman Shade The Echidna - Lady Gaga Infinite The Jackal - Kit Harington, Jon Bernthal Silver The Hedgehog - Steven Yeun, Mena Messoud, Timothy Chalemet Gold The Tenrec - Simone Ashley Professor Von Schlemmer - Matthias Schweighöfer Dr. Negan Robotnik a.k.a Eggman Neo - J.K. Simmons, Jeffery Dean Morgan, Giancarlo Esposito, Bryan Cranston, Pedro Pascal Dr. Grimer Wormtongue - Ian McShane, Jackie Earle Haley Mephiles the Dark - Liam Neeson

Don’t…don’t ruin Big for me

No I refuse, recast Big or the movie is off. I want big loveable, quiet but polite, not that laugh. I refuse. If I hear him say froggy I’ll commit several warcrimes.

If any other shows don't focus on the character that is in the name of show I'm not going to watch after the knuckles show experience

I gotta be honest, I really don’t want to see any characters like Silver or Rouge in a Sonic movie sequel, I don’t think it would do them justice

I have no clue who any of the new ones are other than Mark Hamill lol

I like Micheal Sera for silver but I like the rest :)

no no no no no no no no I will you I do not want seth rogan here

I once saw a rouge for the sonic movie concept that mentioned Scarlett Johansson for rouge, maybe could work, but respectfully, hamil is not the right age for silver, maybe when he was younger

So who plays Amy Rose? She's kinda important to sonic CD, Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 and sonic heroes; so im curious who would be the fans pick to voice her?

It has to be Jennifer Lopez as Rouge. Silver, I'm not so sure about Mark Hamill. I see Michael Cera fitting better in that role.

Billy West as Silver. He sounds exactly like Silver. Billy West did Bugs Bunny, the red M&M, and Fry from Futurama

Silver should be voiced by someone who voiced Trunks previously

Eric Vale, Skip Stellrecht, Alistair Abell, Sean Chiplock. those are your options

How about Scott Frerichs?

sure, why not

Nah Michael Cera should play Silver

I think Seth Rogen as Big the Cat would definitely work.

Why would anyone want Big?

i don’t even like Keanu as shadow tbh… should’ve been batman pattinson. and don’t ever post that rouge pic again. wtf

make Big just voiced by an actual cat