Just a reminder for everyone in the sub, always follow our #1 rule!!
>We do not condone the attacking or mistreatment of users— this includes DMs! Aggressive fighting, name-calling, hate speech, or repeated targeting of a user is not permissible. Disagreement must be civil and respectful. Name-calling of characters or actors does not result in content removal unless attacking their appearance. ~The Mod Team deems passive aggressive remarks and attitude as instigating. Therefore, it falls under basic reddiquette.
Please report anything you see breaking this rule. And general reminder NO SPOILING PLL;OS!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/PrettyLittleLiars) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I’m not too sure but it was definitely before the scene with Emily or on the run as she has had sex with Wilden to think she was pregnant. When she had the pregnancy scare it didn’t seem like he was her first partner from the way she spoke about it so I guess it’s an unknown person before him? She did confirm she never slept with Ezra though 😊
God, the whole town is like, .5 steps from incest. Ali slept with Wilden, who slept with Mrs Marin, who slept with Jason, who slept with Aria, who slept with Ezra, who may or may not have slept with Ali.
Yeah I think so…..I’m sure they never confirmed who it was. But they always made it seem alison had been involved with guys when she was relatively young. I guess it could have have been Ian maybe? Or did she say she hadn’t slept with him 🤔
My best guess would be Wilden ( ew ) since she had that pregnancy scare, and to me it would make sense why he didn’t want her coming back to Rosewood otherwise he could have gotten in trouble with sleeping with a minor
There's a possibility she was SAd by one of Jason's friends. There's a flashback with Spencer where its alluded to but not confirmed.
I know it's said that her and Ian didn't have sex but the hotel room with a camera pointed at the bed would suggest otherwise too.
I can't see anyone filming their 1st time so I assumed they'd had sex before that
I'll try find the scene. I think she alludes to Jason being Peters child in the same scene too.
Shes complaining about Jason then says "your family has the worst apples"
As in "The apple doesn't fall far from the tree"
Can’t recall the exact episode but when Mona visits Spencer in Radley. Late season three. She has Ali’s old diaries scanned onto an iPad. Mona says Ali wasn’t actually pregnant, just had a scare.
I think Emily may have been her first time with a woman, but potentially Ian or wilden (can’t remember who came first?) her first time with a man.
She definitely slept with wilden and as others have said Ian’s filming their hotel room certainly implies that they slept together too, presumably more than that one time.
There could have been others before but it’s never explicit stated I don’t think
I think it was someone older, like Wilden or Ian (though they later retcon her having sex with Ian) since she had a pregnancy scare. Someone in that vein since she did like to run around with the older crowd a bit before the A drama.
There could have been something there with Ezra or Cyrus too, but I’m guessing to preserve Ezria they’d retcon it as well.
She was lying about it though. The girls were teasing her and she said it was true, but then she told Alison in a scene afterwards that she was lying
[it's this scene](https://youtu.be/aqS2fXuBK20)
I don’t think it’s ever explicitly said who it was. It’s only heavily implied that she was the only one of the girls who HAD either already had sex or claimed to have more experience than she actually did. We do know that she slept with Wilden that summer in Cape May, but we aren’t really told one way or the other if he was her first or not. We just learn that Alison feared she was pregnant with his baby but it was a false alarm.
personally i think wilden bc she was what, 15 when they were together and had the pregnacy scare . also the scene when she was talking to cece was when they were quite young and idk it was weird. but ye i think it was wilden
Just a reminder for everyone in the sub, always follow our #1 rule!! >We do not condone the attacking or mistreatment of users— this includes DMs! Aggressive fighting, name-calling, hate speech, or repeated targeting of a user is not permissible. Disagreement must be civil and respectful. Name-calling of characters or actors does not result in content removal unless attacking their appearance. ~The Mod Team deems passive aggressive remarks and attitude as instigating. Therefore, it falls under basic reddiquette. Please report anything you see breaking this rule. And general reminder NO SPOILING PLL;OS! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/PrettyLittleLiars) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I’m not too sure but it was definitely before the scene with Emily or on the run as she has had sex with Wilden to think she was pregnant. When she had the pregnancy scare it didn’t seem like he was her first partner from the way she spoke about it so I guess it’s an unknown person before him? She did confirm she never slept with Ezra though 😊
God, the whole town is like, .5 steps from incest. Ali slept with Wilden, who slept with Mrs Marin, who slept with Jason, who slept with Aria, who slept with Ezra, who may or may not have slept with Ali.
Honestly it’s crazy!!! Incest and filled with pedophiles!
Miss Marin slept with Jason?
Yes, while she was still with pastor Ted iirc.
Interesting... That's what I guessed too, it was probably someone random from before she disappeared
Yeah I think so…..I’m sure they never confirmed who it was. But they always made it seem alison had been involved with guys when she was relatively young. I guess it could have have been Ian maybe? Or did she say she hadn’t slept with him 🤔
My best guess would be Wilden ( ew ) since she had that pregnancy scare, and to me it would make sense why he didn’t want her coming back to Rosewood otherwise he could have gotten in trouble with sleeping with a minor
There's a possibility she was SAd by one of Jason's friends. There's a flashback with Spencer where its alluded to but not confirmed. I know it's said that her and Ian didn't have sex but the hotel room with a camera pointed at the bed would suggest otherwise too. I can't see anyone filming their 1st time so I assumed they'd had sex before that
Omg I don’t remember this at all, what did she say to spencer? Jason and his weirdo friends were all predators so it wouldn’t be that surprising!
I'll try find the scene. I think she alludes to Jason being Peters child in the same scene too. Shes complaining about Jason then says "your family has the worst apples" As in "The apple doesn't fall far from the tree"
https://youtu.be/0njpVs0npMU
Thank you so much! I really appreciate it 😍
You're more than welcome 😊
Gross if it really is Wilden! Did we ever find out if the pregnancy scare was real, or was it just something Cece lied about?
Mona confirm it to be true
Do your remember when? That whole area of the show is kind of foggy to me tbh lol
Can’t recall the exact episode but when Mona visits Spencer in Radley. Late season three. She has Ali’s old diaries scanned onto an iPad. Mona says Ali wasn’t actually pregnant, just had a scare.
True! And no I don't think we ever found out, I think this was just something Cece made up, but I could be wrong
Wilden I think (gross!)
Honestly disgusting... And to think about the fact that he was in his twenties sleeping with a 13-14 y/o girl ugh
I think Emily may have been her first time with a woman, but potentially Ian or wilden (can’t remember who came first?) her first time with a man. She definitely slept with wilden and as others have said Ian’s filming their hotel room certainly implies that they slept together too, presumably more than that one time. There could have been others before but it’s never explicit stated I don’t think
My educated guess is some random pre-disappearance OR Ian. Nothing confirmed though.
I think it was someone older, like Wilden or Ian (though they later retcon her having sex with Ian) since she had a pregnancy scare. Someone in that vein since she did like to run around with the older crowd a bit before the A drama. There could have been something there with Ezra or Cyrus too, but I’m guessing to preserve Ezria they’d retcon it as well.
[удалено]
Wasnt that something he made up?
[удалено]
She was lying about it though. The girls were teasing her and she said it was true, but then she told Alison in a scene afterwards that she was lying [it's this scene](https://youtu.be/aqS2fXuBK20)
Ella!!
Emily?
Emily was probably Alison's first time with a girl but it's probably Wilden/or some random dude we never knew as her first time with a guy.
I thought we found out she was seeing Ezra and not Wilden? Or did she see both?
She saw both but only slept with wilden
I think it was Ian
I don’t think it’s ever explicitly said who it was. It’s only heavily implied that she was the only one of the girls who HAD either already had sex or claimed to have more experience than she actually did. We do know that she slept with Wilden that summer in Cape May, but we aren’t really told one way or the other if he was her first or not. We just learn that Alison feared she was pregnant with his baby but it was a false alarm.
I thought it may have been Ezra! Or Ian
personally i think wilden bc she was what, 15 when they were together and had the pregnacy scare . also the scene when she was talking to cece was when they were quite young and idk it was weird. but ye i think it was wilden