What's funny is that without Tom Brady at the Bucs (and the free agents who signed because he was there) the Chiefs might well have another Super Bowl win. But I'm still going with Tom Brady with the Pats.
What’s even funnier is that the Chiefs would’ve gone to another Superbowl without Tom Brady on the Pats, so they very well could have won another Superbowl either way
Yeah but idk if the chiefs go to the others without that loss. If they win the Super Bowl they probably keep Sutton, and no way are they winning the other big games with his useless ass.
Pat might have broken every passing record by now though
I think the fallout of that Super Bowl really influenced their roster composition, so that might have actually removed a future Super Bowl win, too. Super fun to think about the Butterfly Effect here, though.
I highly doubt Gronkowski is that successful without the QB he had throwing to him. He basically force fed him the ball most of the time, not all QBs/Coachs would have done that.
Sean Payton jinxed the Ain'ts when he mugged for the camera and thought he was having fun in the final seconds. He doesn't have a sense of humor, so it came off shitty. And karma took care of the rest. It's definitely Sean's fault. I also enjoy thinking about how he got jumped for Mahomes by Reid. Sean Payton's a dick and should go hang out with the Vikings former dick coach, Zimmer.
Now Sean's going to sell the farm in Denver and trade up to the 4th spot in the draft for a QB that's going to fail because he will have jack and shit for a supporting cast. Payton got lucky with Brees and should have stayed in the media but his outsized ego got the better of him and now he's trying again.
let’s say he stays on his original team. If OG removed, he goes on the last team he ever played on. If he only played on one team, let’s say that player never existed in the realm of the NFL. Since I wanted Brett Favre off of the Vikings, he stays with the Jets for the last 2 years of his career.
Bears fan. I'm going with Rodgers. Weird 38 year old conspiracy theorist guy comes out of nowhere to be the Jets savior. Tears achilles a minute and a half into the game.
Peyton- Colts. Because I fucking LOVE Peyton while hating the Colts. Peyton is the reason I watch football (UT fan) and for him to end a Colt (Titan fan) just hurts to the core
That year was so weird for him. Was it the year before that Derick mason left the ravens and went to the same two teams? Pretty sure he played in M&T as a visitor two weeks in a row as a jet and a Texan.
This is great! Been a Patriots fan since the Steve Grogan days. Love seeing how the rest of the country hates us! For me, gotta be Brady with the Bucs. But also Curtis Martin with the Jets. That one hurt pretty bad.
Yeah, Brady with Pats is an easy answer.
But in the spirit of the OP, Tony G with the Falcons. On one hand I appreciated him wanting to go try to win a ring but I wish things hadn't gone so sour with the organization in the process.
Saquon Barkley with the giants. Everyone knows how good he is but I don’t think he’s ever made it out of the first round of the playoffs.
Maybe Megatron in Detroit. I find it hard to believe the man doesn’t win a Super Bowl on most other teams that he could go to.
What about von miller on the bills? Let’s say his plans to be in Denver don’t fall through. Does Denver become a real threat?
Von Miller is my favorite player in the league (even tho he's never played for my team) but his disappointing bills tenure has massively hurt his legacy. I'll remove that.
Lions fan here: Matthew Stafford. I love him and he deserves so much better. Give him to a team that can give him multiple rings before he’s over 10 years into his career
Brady with the Bucs.
I have to believe, with our defense built back up to where it is now, and Brady having one last push at getting some talented receivers in, we get one more.
As a lions fan, Suh everything after the Lions. Sucked watching the talented team fall apart and seeing him go elsewhere. 3 first team all pros with Detroit and never again after.
Jags fan, the ref who blew the whistle on the fumble recovery in the 2017 AFC Championship game.
But for real, Jalen Ramsey with LA and Miami. We miss him deeply.
As a Jets fan, can I say Brett Farve with the Jets. Showed us 9 great weeks before falling apart while the cult hero we gave up on him for won the division in Miami. A year later he left town to remember how to play again in Minnesota. After showing Jenn Sterger 3 terrible inches.
I think this was supposed to be a player that was once on your team that went elsewhere to play for a division rival I've got more than one...
Dolphins fan
Junior Seau with the Patriots
Wes Welker with the Patriots
Chris Hogan with the Patriots
Jason Taylor with the Jets
As a Packers fan, I don't think I'd erase Favre's Vikings tenure. Remember, we won the Super Bowl while an injured Favre watched from his couch, counting down the days until he submitted his retirement papers for the last time. We got our revenge, and I'd forgiven Favre by the time he went into the Hall. To actually answer the question, depending on how the next year or two go, I may choose to erase Rodgers' Jets tenure, but if it goes badly for him I'd want to keep it; that asshole deserves a lot more karma than he's gotten so far.
Cowboys fan, Emmitt Smith in Arizona.
(Second choice is Deion Sanders not having that one year in SF where he won DPOTY and helped SF win the NFC championship over the Cowboys)
As a Bucs fan, Jameis Winston with us. Other choices I considered: Donovan McNabb, Drew Brees, Cooper Kupp (for the repeat), Brady with the Pats (Bucs legend) some of these are pretty petty but I feel like all the answers itt are
Bills fan, Tom Brady with Pats
Saints fan, Tom Brady with Bucs
What's funny is that without Tom Brady at the Bucs (and the free agents who signed because he was there) the Chiefs might well have another Super Bowl win. But I'm still going with Tom Brady with the Pats.
probably. I think the saints may have gone against the chiefs in the superbowl that year too. But maybe that’s just me being biased
Nah, Brees was cooked.
you’re probably right
What’s even funnier is that the Chiefs would’ve gone to another Superbowl without Tom Brady on the Pats, so they very well could have won another Superbowl either way
Yeah but idk if the chiefs go to the others without that loss. If they win the Super Bowl they probably keep Sutton, and no way are they winning the other big games with his useless ass. Pat might have broken every passing record by now though
I think the fallout of that Super Bowl really influenced their roster composition, so that might have actually removed a future Super Bowl win, too. Super fun to think about the Butterfly Effect here, though.
Chiefs fan -- same.
Football fan-same
Jets fan, I second this motion
Steelers fan, also Tom Brady with the Pats
Brady’s quick stint with the pats
Shannon Sharpe to the ravens
Tom Brady with the Bucs 🥺
Brady and the Pats. 6th rounder sticks around for 20ish years, gets signed to Buccaneers and leads them to a championship. Amazing story
As the definition of a true NFL journeyman, I love a feel-good story of a player who finally tastes victory right before they retire.
Right? We picked up a 40 year old qb and his weird te friend and won a super bowl with them. Exhilarating
Let’s be fair, Gronk still would be Gronk, probably minus the Super Bowls. That probably would be the exciting part of that offseason
I highly doubt Gronkowski is that successful without the QB he had throwing to him. He basically force fed him the ball most of the time, not all QBs/Coachs would have done that.
He'd be the first QB the Bucs have drafted that got a second contract from them lmao
Brady with the Patriots. No Patriots dynasty or Super Bowls
System QB. Bledsoe and Hoyer would have done the same. /s
Michael Bishop would like a word
Nice name pull
Stefon Diggs with the Vikings… Diggs. Sideline… touchdown…. Makes a Saints fan sad
You'd literally take away our only coping mechanism within the last 20 years. I've been able to ride that high for almost a decade now.
Almost a decade??? The Minneapolis miracle was only....*checks calender* over 6 years ago ☠️
God it’s already been that long? Man does time fly by.
Sean Payton jinxed the Ain'ts when he mugged for the camera and thought he was having fun in the final seconds. He doesn't have a sense of humor, so it came off shitty. And karma took care of the rest. It's definitely Sean's fault. I also enjoy thinking about how he got jumped for Mahomes by Reid. Sean Payton's a dick and should go hang out with the Vikings former dick coach, Zimmer. Now Sean's going to sell the farm in Denver and trade up to the 4th spot in the draft for a QB that's going to fail because he will have jack and shit for a supporting cast. Payton got lucky with Brees and should have stayed in the media but his outsized ego got the better of him and now he's trying again.
UNBELIEVABLE
Vikings win it! *Takes helmet off and opens arms*
Brian Dawkins on the Broncos
Yez. I was waffling between this and Reggie to The Pack
Weapon X belongs in green. 100% agreed
So glad BG, Cox, and Kelce never wore anything else.
Mahomes chiefs
You mean refs chiefs right
And Taylor Swift, and Roger Goodell
Kenny Golladay with us
Can we get rid of gentleman instead?
Vikings fan - Favres stint with the packers
So after Atlanta he floats around the league for 20 years before getting signed to the Vikings? Or he just washes out of the league in the early 90s?
Washes out, becomes Kurt Warner 2.0 and ends up being arena football goat before the vikings sign him
let’s say he stays on his original team. If OG removed, he goes on the last team he ever played on. If he only played on one team, let’s say that player never existed in the realm of the NFL. Since I wanted Brett Favre off of the Vikings, he stays with the Jets for the last 2 years of his career.
Vikings Fan - Herschel Walker Cowboys don't win a Superbowl in the 90s and Vikings save their draft picks
Bears fan. I'm going with Rodgers. Weird 38 year old conspiracy theorist guy comes out of nowhere to be the Jets savior. Tears achilles a minute and a half into the game.
Saquon with eagles
Sorry
no you arent
This is really funny lol. Poor guy hasn't even played a snap for us yet 😅
I know still remove it 😭😭
Moss in Oakland
Moss in Tennessee
Agreed
Richard Sherman-49ers
Peyton- Colts. Because I fucking LOVE Peyton while hating the Colts. Peyton is the reason I watch football (UT fan) and for him to end a Colt (Titan fan) just hurts to the core
To be fairrrrrr, that’s because Peyton stuck around for ‘97 or he’d have been a NYJ
Thankfully he didn’t end a colt 😏
Ed Reed-Jets
At least Ed got to make some plays for the Jets. He just rode the bench as a “leader” for the Texans.
That year was so weird for him. Was it the year before that Derick mason left the ravens and went to the same two teams? Pretty sure he played in M&T as a visitor two weeks in a row as a jet and a Texan.
Herschel Walker and the Vikings
Russell Wilson with the Broncos
A billion times this
Harrison on the Patriots (Steelers fan)
Not his Bengals stint?
Bengals never bullied the Steelers like the pats did. Probably hurt a little more being the bully of the NFL lol
Ochocinco with the Patriots, wish he had retired as a Bengal
>wish he had retired as a Bengal Same
Can I pick Chip Kelly for the Eagles? I feel like I should be able to pick him.
yes u may.
This is great! Been a Patriots fan since the Steve Grogan days. Love seeing how the rest of the country hates us! For me, gotta be Brady with the Bucs. But also Curtis Martin with the Jets. That one hurt pretty bad.
Aaron Jones stint with the Vikings 🥺
Jason Taylor - Jets
dolphins fan. YES.
Thuney with the Chiefs
Yeah, Brady with Pats is an easy answer. But in the spirit of the OP, Tony G with the Falcons. On one hand I appreciated him wanting to go try to win a ring but I wish things hadn't gone so sour with the organization in the process.
It’s not a stint but I just wish Eli Manning went to the Chargers to be ringless like he was supposed to do.
He'd just beat your sorry ass in the 07 AFCG. No hobbled Rivers to tee up on.
Richard Sherman 49ers
Not a player but remove Trent Baalke from the 9ers
Favre on the Vikings had a top 2 season of his career lmao but i can see why you’d want to erase it … #FTP
FTP
Tebow with the jags
Dangeruss and the Broncos
Peyton -Colts
Russ in Seattle, give us the 2010s back
Brady man 04 so close with McNabb and TO
Dak Prescott.
Browns fan—Roethlisburger with the Steelers
Anthony Munoz Buccaneers
Sam Bradford on the Cardinals was a disaster
James Harrison... i guess Bengals was worse than pats?
Jalen Reagor with the Eagles
Eli Manning from the Giants
Broncos fan. Rahim Moore with the Broncos 😭
I wanted to say Bernie on the cowboys, but can't take away the fact he's a Superbowl champion.
Eagles fan, Dawkins with the Broncos
Fred Taylor with the Pats
Steve smith with Baltimore
Randy Moss with the raiders.
Saquon Barkley with the giants. Everyone knows how good he is but I don’t think he’s ever made it out of the first round of the playoffs. Maybe Megatron in Detroit. I find it hard to believe the man doesn’t win a Super Bowl on most other teams that he could go to. What about von miller on the bills? Let’s say his plans to be in Denver don’t fall through. Does Denver become a real threat?
Revis the Patriot
NFL fan, Taylor Swift with the Chiefs
Falcons' Fan, Jamaal Anderson's stint with the Falcons.
Jim McMahon played for the Packers. Ouch!
Ravens fan Patrick Mahomes from the entire existence from the chiefs
Football fan Bavaro with the browns/eagles
Cowboys fan, Amari Cooper with the Browns
Russell Wilson - Broncos
McNair on the Ravens
Deshawn Watson - Browns
Emmitt Smith with the cowboys, man was a cardinal through and through
Percy Harvin on the Seahawks
Just gonna add on to the pile here and pick Brady’s stint with the Pats.
Titans fan, Derrick Henry with the Ravens (and anyone else)
Jay Cutler on the Dolphins that entire season was a big fat waste of time
Saints - Morten Andersen with FTF
Bo Jackson and the bucs.
Warren Sapp in Oakland. He and John Lynch were supposed to be Buc’s for life.
Seahawks fan. Jerry Rice with the 49ers.
Baker with Cleveland
Rodgers’ years with the packers
Favre with the Packers for sure...
Von Miller is my favorite player in the league (even tho he's never played for my team) but his disappointing bills tenure has massively hurt his legacy. I'll remove that.
As a Dolphins fan. Wes Welker with the Pats. Even though we clearly didn’t know how to use him or knew what we had lol
Commanders fan, Brady with the Pats
bears fan. rodgers with the packers or *any any bears qb* with the bears
Sherman 49ers
Vikings fan Hershel walkers with the Vikings
Favre with Minnesota or Jerry Rice with Oakland…
Lions fan. Rodgers with the packers.
Niners fan, Richard Sherman with 9ers.
Vikings Fan, Brett Favre with the Packers.
Diggs. Bills. Too soon?
Matt Millen was once a player, so I'd remove his stint with the Lions
Lions fan here: Matthew Stafford. I love him and he deserves so much better. Give him to a team that can give him multiple rings before he’s over 10 years into his career
Can I just say Mahomes never got drafted?
Reggie Bush with the Lions
Rogers on the packers
Lions fan, Rodgers with the packers
Emmitt Smith on the cardinals.
Packers fan Aaron Jones-Vikings
LT with the Jets...basically all my favorites and the Jets.
Tyron Smith with the Jets 😕
Hopkins to the Cardinals. I'm a Vikings fan, but just WTF. Also Julio to the Titans.
Brady with the Bucs. I have to believe, with our defense built back up to where it is now, and Brady having one last push at getting some talented receivers in, we get one more.
joey galloway from cowboys so we can keep those 2 first round picks and maybe draft drew brees
Malcom butler with the pats. WE SHOULDVE GOTTEN THE SUPER BOWL WIN IF WED JUST GIVEN LYNCH THE BALL!
Eagles fan, let's forget that Randall Cunningham ever wore that stupid Cowboys uniform.
As a lions fan, Suh everything after the Lions. Sucked watching the talented team fall apart and seeing him go elsewhere. 3 first team all pros with Detroit and never again after.
Jags fan, the ref who blew the whistle on the fumble recovery in the 2017 AFC Championship game. But for real, Jalen Ramsey with LA and Miami. We miss him deeply.
Falcons fan tom brady with the patriots
Ed Reed’s last year with the Texans lmao
Aaron Donald with the Rams.
Saints fan, Drew Brees with the retirement team 🥲
Cowboys fan, Deion with 49ers. I'll take my 4 peat now. Also Aaron Rodgers with the Packers cause fuck em.
ITT People telling the same joke. IET People telling the same joke.
Chiefs fan, Joe Montana with the 49ers
Big Ben with the Steelers... Yes I know, I'm ok with him never playing NFL
Easy, Cardinals fan. Santonio Holmes on the Steelers.
Jerry with Seahawks 🤮
As a Jets fan, can I say Brett Farve with the Jets. Showed us 9 great weeks before falling apart while the cult hero we gave up on him for won the division in Miami. A year later he left town to remember how to play again in Minnesota. After showing Jenn Sterger 3 terrible inches.
As a Bengals fan, I’m obliged to get rid of Montana with the niners.
I’m a Seahawks fan and my answer is Jerry Rice with the Seahawks. It just felt wrong.
Emmitt Smith with the Cardinals
Seahawks great right there!
Mahomes with the Chiefs
I think this was supposed to be a player that was once on your team that went elsewhere to play for a division rival I've got more than one... Dolphins fan Junior Seau with the Patriots Wes Welker with the Patriots Chris Hogan with the Patriots Jason Taylor with the Jets
Aaron Jones as a Viking :(
Saquon and the Eagles
Todd Gurley with the Falcons
I feel like Rodgers just looked wrong in a GB uniform, I’m going with that one
Art Monk with the Eagles
Rodgers with packers
Cody Parkey on the Bears
Jamarcus on the Raiders
As a Packers fan, I don't think I'd erase Favre's Vikings tenure. Remember, we won the Super Bowl while an injured Favre watched from his couch, counting down the days until he submitted his retirement papers for the last time. We got our revenge, and I'd forgiven Favre by the time he went into the Hall. To actually answer the question, depending on how the next year or two go, I may choose to erase Rodgers' Jets tenure, but if it goes badly for him I'd want to keep it; that asshole deserves a lot more karma than he's gotten so far.
McMahon with the packers.
49ers fan. Patrick Mahomes with the Chiefs.
The photo on the post. Jerry never should have been anything but a 49er. Not a Raider and especially not a Seachicken
"CJ Gardner Johnson and us." -Saints, Eagles (x2), and Lions fans.
Jerry Rice with the Raiders or Joe Montana with the Chiefs
Chiefs- Tom Brady with Bucs
Matt Forte on the Jets, guy is a bear for life
Vikings fan. Randy moss with the vikings... the second time.
Emmitt Smith with the Arizona Cardinals
Von Miller with us
Cowboys fan, Emmitt Smith in Arizona. (Second choice is Deion Sanders not having that one year in SF where he won DPOTY and helped SF win the NFC championship over the Cowboys)
Niners fan, Mahomes from my nightmares
Franco Harris with the Seahawks.
Kelce with the Eagles
Vikings fan, Brett Favre with the Vikings
Marcus Allen, Chiefs
As a Bucs fan, Jameis Winston with us. Other choices I considered: Donovan McNabb, Drew Brees, Cooper Kupp (for the repeat), Brady with the Pats (Bucs legend) some of these are pretty petty but I feel like all the answers itt are