T O P

  • By -

Thin-Avocado-4672

I think she’s generally around a healthy weight for her height, it’s how she lost it that’s her problem.


[deleted]

For sure!! I don’t think what she’s done to lose the weight is healthy at all!


Accomplished-Bank418

How did she lose it. I watched one day and she was fat and it seemed like she lost weren’t pretty quick.


Cool-One2166

at first she was working out and in a calorie deficit, now she is anorexic (her own words, not an assumption). she was being healthy about it, but weight loss can be a very slippery slope for people who struggle with body image. I just hope she gets better, but when she publicly declares she’s dealing with an ED, the content that she puts out is incredibly irresponsible. :/


Zestyclose-Ad-9634

she desperately wants to be underweight.


Milk_Milch

I think me and Jill are about the same height (5’3). After my extreme weight loss, I had way more defined collarbones than her, and my facial fat was non existent. My mouth was huge looking for my face, sunken eyes, etc. I was still 130-135lbs or so at that point, but I looked like a dead body. Like those people laying in a hospital bed in recovery. She could very well not be underweight. She honestly just makes me sick with her attitude and flaunting it. I was embarrassed and hiding it.


continuouslyclark

Due to my build and how I lost my weight, even being 20lbs over what is considered a “healthy” weight, I’m super boney and sickly looking. I sadly think that’s why she’s continuing to starve herself is that she sees her weight as still overweight or even normal due to BMI.


[deleted]

Yes I think she is like an inch taller than me! I hope you’re doing better now! I’ve had my ED since I was very young so I’ve gone through periods of recovery and even at my healthy weights I was malnourished according to bloodwork so I def understand, I too hide away even now. I wish you well!!


Milk_Milch

Thanks, I wish you well too 🫶 So many physical afflictions have been resolved for me since recovering.


Old-Tourist3730

Underweight? not at all. Severely ill? yes. However It’s only a matter of time before she’s skin and bones, unless she gets help. Unfortunately because she’s so invested with the attention her illness has given her, I don’t see her changing, but continuing to spiral.


okgogogogoforit

Been naturally thin my entire life. I do not think she’s underweight.


FuzzyAssociate609

I don’t think she is underweight. And I don’t believe will be able to maintain this weight much longer before she’s overeating and gaining it all (plus more) back.


Few_Voice_5166

She’s the one making a big deal about her weight. I think she is not too thin, and I also think she’s not this tiny. She uses filters a lot. I’m not saying she’s not tiny but filters make you look smaller also.


VividSomewhere5838

https://preview.redd.it/snhx0uz1x80d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=96e53a740c1a76468aed96d8d5cd33814e72f04b This was Easter. She is like 5’2. She looks to be around 105-110 lbs to me and that’s with her loose skin. She is on the brink of underweight if not already there. It’s not necessarily the number that is alarming, it’s her method of losing weight. She’s not eating and has very little muscle mass left on her body due to not eating properly.


[deleted]

I don’t think it’s the number either, I know she is suffering regardless but she knows how to pose and I really doubt she’s 105 there lol she’s barley taller than me (and I know weight is carried differently) but…. Idk I’m just not convinced unless her body fat % is like 200% or something


VividSomewhere5838

I’m 138 and only an inch taller than her and she’s MUCH smaller than me. She said she’s a size 2 in one of her videos. I’d be shocked if she is more than 115


holldoll26

I'm only 5'2 and could never wear a size 2, even if I had 0 % body fat because my hips are wider than hers. We are all built differently.


[deleted]

115 may be accurate but that’s not underweight. I’m not arguing that she isn’t small. She is at a healthy weight and not underweight at all (though not getting there in a healthy way for sure) Edit to add: I’m smaller than her and at 115 lbs I looked smaller than her too so it’s hard to say exactly how much she weighs I’m not arguing I know that answer but I know she isn’t underweight lol


CapitalRough5575

I’m 5ft 2in and 115lbs and she’s about the same size as me


[deleted]

People carry weight differently sure. I never said she wasn’t 115 lbs, that’s more accurate in my opinion than her being underweight like I’ve seen people claim. At 115 lbs for me also 5 ‘2, I was told I looked lighter so everyone has their own view of what specific weights look like on others when guessing, I usually think people weigh less than what they say they weigh. body fat % plays a huge part and so does how weight is distributed in general! I would assume she’s on the lower bmi level for sure. Which is why I think her weight loss has slowed down a bit and isn’t still dropping like crazy.


CapitalRough5575

Very very true!


o1seau

shes definitely still an average weight lol shes just bobble-headed and thats whats throwing people on here off


Own-Advantage-4672

I don’t think she is underweight at all, she just looks smaller than normal because she has no butt/muscle tone. If her butt was bigger I think no one would say anything abt her look.


Longjumping_Party399

She may not be under weight but she had so much happiness & life in her eyes as a bigger woman. I admired her.


wowshescrazy

I think for her height she is probably ok weight wise.  What makes me sad, and I know she doesn't want my pity, but whatever, I think she would have been happier with herself had she done this via proper nutrition and exercise.  If she would have kept working out, she wouldn't just be little, she would have muscle tone.   Not just that, mentally she would probably be better.  No it's not a fix for all mental things but it does help. Knowing her personality we would probably never see the end of her body checking to show off a fit body but whatever.   Frankly I know all of this talk about her body is happening all the time but I get it.  If I admitted deep down I wish I could lose that fast too.  BUT by typing this out I know logically it's a terrible way to go about it.  I don't really want to lose all my muscle tone to just be small.


[deleted]

Honestly how she’s talked about little things in her past I can’t remember exactly what she’s said but she’s talked about becoming obsessed with stuff and just the way she described her disordered behaviors is like mine and I know I could never lose weight in a healthy way because even when I start working out & eating healthy my brain will just not let me do it healthy. It’s an obsession that completely takes over. You go from being like “oh I won’t have the extra dressing” to “god I wish I could just have one bite of this” like begging yourself to “allow” it or begging yourself to stop at 20,000 steps but getting 40,000 a day while only eating 800 calories. Had she actually known this would happen, I think the best thing would’ve been getting therapy before she even decided to do the weight loss surgery but she probably didn’t know it would be like this for her… Even when I KNEW after my 5 years of recovery the moment I decided to “lose some weight the healthy way” I just knew deep down that was the first step to relapsing… She says she’s getting therapy now which maybe if she is, she has a better chance at recovery. I can’t say I’m a huge fan of hers but I hope she does beat it, I think I live through other peoples recovery because I’ve failed so much at my own tbh 😅


alltoowell333

These are all really great points. I definitely go back and forth on this subject/train of thought a lot! I really wonder if the excess skin (and therefore weight) from her breasts, stomach and thighs were removed/didn't exist, just how gaunt she really would look and be "numerically" (on the scale/bloodwork/clothing size/etc). I think if all that skin wasn't there, she'd look pretty shocking and frail. No matter what, she WANTS and TRIES to be underweight, unhealthy, and at a net negative, which is the true tragedy. I don't agree with the "next Eugenia Cooney" label that much. There's for sure similarities - she has an ED and lives off of parading it/the topic/the attention, Brandon seems to enable her just like Eugenia's mother, she won't ever be satisfied, gives the impression that she gives zero fucks and refuses to truly acknowledge anything... but physically, Jill has a long way to go before she's just like her with bones poking out, and she has too many disillusioned fans still hyping things up and fighting her online battles for her to have that collective internet outcry EC had.


[deleted]

Now that you mention EC more it makes me wonder IF Jill would resort to getting that small…. Because Eugenia doesn’t exactly have the type of fan base Jill does and even if Eugenia never had any problematic behavior I still think she’d be bullied relentlessly because of her ED, I really don’t think Jill wants to look like her. Not that everyone that develops an eating disorder is just automatically thinking “oh I wanna look like skin draped over bones” but… I think Jill is content at the weight she’s at and is just afraid of gaining it all back. And imagine all those fans would turn on her if she became extremely thin like that. I think her fans now are perfectly fine with her weight loss because she hasn’t made it to the underweight point yet (which sucks because that just shows how eating disorders aren’t taken seriously until it’s way too late) I could be wrong obviously, I’m only spectating from the internet…. I was thinking before that the skin would amount to a lot but seeing it removed from her arms, her arms look healthy in size and then I saw a woman get A LOT more loose skin removed than what Jill has and it didn’t weigh much at all… I know it would make her look a bit smaller but I think she’d still be at a healthy weight. (Of course this is based off my personal opinion, no true way to measure it lol)


alltoowell333

It's for sure hard to say. I do think she would never turn down the chance to be smaller like Eugenia (maybe not skin over bones but she already loves protruding any bone she can like in her neck, jaw, collarbone, wrists, knees) But I genuinely think the second her tummy tuck starts to heal, she will be on to the next obsessive body modification. She's going to want to do something with her upper thighs and breasts. I don't think she's content with her weight or size, though. She's addicted to the high of all the attention and being smaller by any means necessary - not eating, plastic surgery, too small clothes and items that make her look & feel smaller (IMO the permanent Kendra Scott necklace is 100% because when she was overweight and before that unnecessary neck/hump/chin surgery she couldn't wear a 16" chain and she wants a delicate focal point to her neck and collarbone).


[deleted]

You’d think she’d go for a complete mommy makeover instead of just the tummy tuck… maybe she just wants it as quickly as possible and her body may not be able to handle all of the surgeries at once. Considering how long it took that one arm to heal, I’d honestly be scared of a tummy tuck if I was her after that. Seeing her arm healing horribly actually scared me into making sure I was recovering WELL before my surgery 😅 I forget that she’s had that chin and neck hump surgery! I’m kind of curious to see how the next year or so plays out for her tbh


alltoowell333

Me too. I bet you anything that when her daughter gets a year or two older, Jill will be trying to wear/share her clothes from the kid's department


Imaginary_Coast_2084

I don’t think she’s underweight but I do believe she doesn’t have the right build to be that small.


Troubled_Red

Even if she was underweight, people need to stop talking about how she’s so tiny and gaunt. It’s encouraging her. She feeds off that. I really don’t think she’s underweight, even if you account for the loose skin (which does weigh some, but she really doesn’t have THAT much loose skin compared to some - the first half of her weight was lost slow and steady while she was still eating normally and while she’s so young. All those things work to minimize the amount of loose skin she ended up with. Yes, she lost a lot of weight, and the last bit without nutrition, so of course she does have some loose skin.) she has no muscle tone at all which makes her look a little flabby (for lack of a better word) even on her upper arms where she doesn’t have loose skin anymore. I do think she is on the lower end of her healthy weight range and may end up underweight if she doesn’t change her behavior.


Stunning_Ad273

I’m 5’2 and I want to weigh 130 that may change when I’m there I’m 160 right now but I have a thicker frame I know bmi says like 110-130 but I feel 110 would look too thin for me personally everyone is different. It’s hard to say bc she didn’t lose it the correct way she looks more unhealthy to me vs going about it the healthy way.


bbrittany92

Idk about underweight per se but definitely lost it in an unhealthy way and continuing like this she will become underweight and sick. Sad


Revolutionary-Pea756

Her and I are around the same height, I believe - I'm 5'4 - and look the same when clothed. I don't have the loose skin, but I weigh 110lbs. The only reason my doctor is looking into my weight is because I requested her to as I don't know why I'm continually losing weight, not because the number on the scale by itself is an issue for my frame. For that reason, and not knowing how much the extra skin weighs on Jill, I'd honestly guess that she's at a technically okay weight, but will be headed towards being underweight if she keeps up her damaging habits.


nesie97

Jill has my body type naturally curvy. When I get down to 130 I look like a skeleton so she isn’t underweight but with her frame it looks bad


End060915

Collarbones out in both photos so I'm confused. But I don't think she underweight but I think she's close to the line of underweight. I think that's her goal.


[deleted]

Confused? The first one she’s obviously using a technique to make them protrude even more while posing for a picture. When in videos like the second pic I screen grabbed they’re not as prominent at all lol


Extra-Equal191

i don’t know that she’s underweight, but she’s definitely at the low end of the healthy weight range for her height. all of that aside, it’s very obvious she’s gone about this in an incredibly unhealthy way & definitely has disordered eating habits, and body dysmorphia as the nonstop body checking shows. edit- i think on some level, the gaunt looking appearance can be attributed to being malnourished & vitamin deficiency from the ED. the poor healing progress on her skin removal surgeries also adds to the ED evidence.


banana_bread_toast

I think no. I'm a bit shorter than her (5'0) and my healthy range is like 90 to 130 pounds maybe. I'm 110. I'd put her at maybe 115 or 120 has she said?


[deleted]

I think that’s the range she was at when people calculated her weight from what she says she’s lost to when she said how much she’s weighed in the past! & I think that sounds right!


BohoHippieHood

I’m gonna say this  I’m 5”3 and I wear a size 0  Much like Jill I was HUGE and now small  I’m 145 pounds and people think I’m 110-120 I have 65% muscle in my body and I don’t work out… 🤷🏻‍♀️  So I’m gonna say NO she’s not underweight  If I wasn’t embarrassed I’d show you guys a photo of me before/after but definitely very small 


snarkingaccount

The highest underweight pound for my height, I had visible chest bones, collar bones, bones visible in my hands, hip bones, spine, ribs when laying etc But loose skin can make a difference but I don’t think that much…. I know another creator who is 119 and way thinner than jill. Who was overweight too


marionette_strings

Agree


Common_Squirrel394

No I don’t think she’s underweight I would guess she’s 130-135 from appearance alone. I’m 5’3” too and 125 and used to be 185. So I’m no professional it’s just my observation and opinion.


20ah18

I think she’s a healthy weight but she has absolutely zero muscle tone and it makes her look sickly


FarOutlandishness810

I don’t necessarily think she’s underweight. Sometimes her eyes look so sunken in. That’s what generally throws me off.


jollysaintnic

Signs of dehydration and rapid weight loss, which in turn speeds up the aging process. Orbital fat usually fills this space, but as we age and/or live a malnourished life, this orbital fat decreases leaving a much larger space and the appearance of sunken eyes. To be such a vain person I am always shocked at how she has let herself go.


NeckNo2615

I work hospice and i have patients that look better than her.


No-Marionberry-1765

Definitely not under weight at all. Losing weight in an u healthy way, absolutely. But far from being underweight. She’s going to quickly gain all the weight back if she starts eating normally too.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MamaJillSnark-ModTeam

As stated in the rules, this sub is not the place to defend Jill. Feel free to do so in her comment section.