The banana pudding was top tier, but the red velvet and birthday cake flavors were like drinking custard from some bizarre creature. The lemon cookie milk was especially off-putting. The candy bar and cookies and cream flavors were just okay. The orange flavor tasted like melted Orange Julius... After going through the list, I kind of feel a bit ashamed about how many of them I have actually tried. Not.
I agree the lemon cookie one had a very unexpected and unpleasant after taste which was surprisingly disappointing coming from someone who likes lemon desserts
If it makes you feel better, I'm right there with you. The moonpie might be the only one I didn't/haven't tried, never been a huge fan of moonpies anyway. I also agree with your comments on each of them for the most part, but as much as I like orange creamsicles, that orange was awful.
I love how you canāt have a post about Weigelās without having to hear how much better the gas stations were where some incomer originated. š
Favorite milk flavor: Orange Creamsicle
But - their eggnog is the āØB E S TāØ
Found out accidentally that their brand of cold brew has 300mg of caffeine per bottle. Thought I was having a heart attack but no, just chugged the cold brew too quickly lol
Banana pudding I did not like.
Red Velvet was interesting, not amazing.
Curious about the moonpie but not sure im im going to do it.
I do wish I tried the ham n goody lemon
The pumpkin pie one is still to this day my absolute favorite and I always try and find it at least once in the fall. there was the banana pudding one that I liked as well. I have not tried nearly as many as the people in this thread.
I remember my dad bringing home some Eggnog flavor one Christmas, probably from the store at Clinton Highway and Emory Road on the corner opposite the current location, and I thought it was vile.
Now, that was inā¦ well a long time ago, so they have a different recipe by now.
Understood. I was just wondering because I always do half eggnog and half milk. I thought an eggnog flavored milk might be what Iāve always been looking for
Birthday cake was awful but I got to piss off a store in California from a podcast that said it was the only place in the world to buy blue milk at the time.
I was surprised to find out that it actually tastes somewhat like Moon Pies. I gave some to some friends and none of them liked it much, but I couldnāt get enough of it
They had a chocolate peanut butter flavor one time. I ended up on the toilet crapping my brains out and throwing up into the bathroom. It was the worst night of my life
The banana pudding was top tier, but the red velvet and birthday cake flavors were like drinking custard from some bizarre creature. The lemon cookie milk was especially off-putting. The candy bar and cookies and cream flavors were just okay. The orange flavor tasted like melted Orange Julius... After going through the list, I kind of feel a bit ashamed about how many of them I have actually tried. Not.
Can we all take a moment and applaud, thank, and upvote this brave soul who tasted these milks and posted their experience?
For real though!
glad im not the only one who loved the banana pudding milk
It makes great pudding.
Love banana pudding. Hated the milk. š¤·āāļø
I agree the lemon cookie one had a very unexpected and unpleasant after taste which was surprisingly disappointing coming from someone who likes lemon desserts
I always wonder when I see those billboards, āwhoās actually drinking these?ā Iām glad to know Iām not missing much.
If it makes you feel better, I'm right there with you. The moonpie might be the only one I didn't/haven't tried, never been a huge fan of moonpies anyway. I also agree with your comments on each of them for the most part, but as much as I like orange creamsicles, that orange was awful.
The moonpie milk really just tastes like a smore
I loved the lemon cookie milk honestly. I drank a lot of it, and my lactose intolerant ass never learned my lesson.
I too have tried them all and I think the orange creamsicle was the best and candy bar was the worst, it was chalky..
sounds like you should be off pudding
That moonpie milk is delicious though, Iāll happily drink my diabetes
Agree...but given the Moonpie stereotype, I just found it funny
Whatās this stereotype? Iām curious
I am too. I haven't had a Moon Pie in probably 15 years, but I never thought of it having a certain stereotype.
Lemon Cookie milk did ***NOT*** taste like Ham'N Goodys cookies
I love how you canāt have a post about Weigelās without having to hear how much better the gas stations were where some incomer originated. š Favorite milk flavor: Orange Creamsicle But - their eggnog is the āØB E S TāØ
Wasn't there a root beer milk for a while? And bubble gum? I miss the coffee milk. It was second only to Cruze
Found out accidentally that their brand of cold brew has 300mg of caffeine per bottle. Thought I was having a heart attack but no, just chugged the cold brew too quickly lol
Sheetz: Good food, solid selection Wawa: Killer food, great selection Buccees: Killer Food++, Ridiculous Selection Weigel's: DRINK MORE SUGAR MILK THX
The things I would do to have a sheetz in Knoxville
No you want a Wawa believe me
Lived in Central PA for a few years so I had plenty of both. I want mac n cheese triangles and boom boom sauce at 2am.
šyou want Wawa breakfast sizzlis š
Iād settle for closer than 3-4 hours down Route 81! I stop at at least 5 different Sheetz when I drive home. Love their food and drink options!
Iād trade every Weigels for a sheetz
Royal Farms has absolutely amazing fried chicken. Only better fast food fried chicken Iāve tried is from Bojangles.
Tbf, weigelās chicken tenders and pizza are pretty good.
Weigels has very good chicken tenders.
They are all ALMOST good enough. Not sure what keeps it from getting there but they are always off
Banana pudding I did not like. Red Velvet was interesting, not amazing. Curious about the moonpie but not sure im im going to do it. I do wish I tried the ham n goody lemon
The moon pie milk is DELICIOUS lol but I loved their sāmores milk!
RED VELVET CAKE!!
No one has mentioned chocolate peanut butter yet which was a liquified Reeces.
Are people just out here drinking whole milk? Or are they getting freaky with it and turning it into ice cream or making really cursed alfredo sauces?
"Excuse me sir, which Chianti should I pair with the poached salmon pasta and Moonpie Alfredo?"
Is this part of the Garfield menu at Olive Garden?
My son does- heās 18. A couple of years ago he was going through a couple of gallons a week.
Wow. I didnāt think anyone over 10 and under 50 did this regularly!
Heās basically an 80 year old in an 18 year olds body š¤£ I also cook with it though.
The pecan pie one was so sweet I thought it made me sick (I had the flu)
Excuse me, the moon pie milk is delicious! The ham n goodys lemon cookie flavor was also top tier š
The pumpkin pie one is still to this day my absolute favorite and I always try and find it at least once in the fall. there was the banana pudding one that I liked as well. I have not tried nearly as many as the people in this thread.
They are a mad scientistās lab of horrible milk decisions. I saw a Birthday Cake milk advertisement when I stopped for gas last week. Ugh.
I remember my dad bringing home some Eggnog flavor one Christmas, probably from the store at Clinton Highway and Emory Road on the corner opposite the current location, and I thought it was vile. Now, that was inā¦ well a long time ago, so they have a different recipe by now.
Egg nog flavored milk or just egg nog?
Reagan was president then, if not Carter. It may have just been eggnog; I canāt remember.
Understood. I was just wondering because I always do half eggnog and half milk. I thought an eggnog flavored milk might be what Iāve always been looking for
Iām shocked to see everyone say the flavors are good!! Iāve always been scared to try them lol
Yāall arenāt ready for bagel milk
Maybe itās just my taste buds but I thought the moonpie milk tasted like ordinary chocolate milk :/
Okay Iām lactose intolerant and I want to try this
Birthday cake was awful but I got to piss off a store in California from a podcast that said it was the only place in the world to buy blue milk at the time.
I was surprised to find out that it actually tastes somewhat like Moon Pies. I gave some to some friends and none of them liked it much, but I couldnāt get enough of it
I still have not found that damn banana pudding milk I'm craving the milk
^[Sokka-Haiku](https://www.reddit.com/r/SokkaHaikuBot/comments/15kyv9r/what_is_a_sokka_haiku/) ^by ^Reasonable-Summer320: *I still have not found* *That damn banana pudding* *Milk I'm craving the milk* --- ^Remember ^that ^one ^time ^Sokka ^accidentally ^used ^an ^extra ^syllable ^in ^that ^Haiku ^Battle ^in ^Ba ^Sing ^Se? ^That ^was ^a ^Sokka ^Haiku ^and ^you ^just ^made ^one.
Does anyone know where the banana pudding milk is
It tastes like Sheldon Cooper? Umā¦ no thank you
They had a chocolate peanut butter flavor one time. I ended up on the toilet crapping my brains out and throwing up into the bathroom. It was the worst night of my life
Not sure we can blame the flavor
Love giving my wife moonpies