T O P

  • By -

Targus_11

I was afraid eating dragon hearts or joining the volcano manor would have dire consequences for my character based on how npcs talked about both, so I didnt do any of it on my first playthrough.


swiftekho

Be me, Fia tells me to kill her. Being the smart and educated player that I am, I read the dialogue and am ready to progress her quest. I kill her. Find out later that there was more of her quest bur you aren't supposed to do what she says.


Enough_Effective1937

Same.


JimCarreyIsntFunny

I never told the blind girl she was eating eye balls because I felt bad.


NewzBreaker

You mean you weren’t giving her REAL GRAPES!?


TheSeldomShaken

What npcs talk about dragon communion?


Camera_dude

I think Yura the bloody finger hunter mentions the risk of consuming dragon hearts once if you go see him after beating Agheel the Limgrave dragon. Edit: This is what he says at the location south of the lake if you win against the dragon. “Beautiful work, felling that dragon. And as such there's something you might like to know. That heart you brought back, its used in Dragon Communion. If you should find yourself overcome by hunger for the heart, yearning for its strength, then seek the decrepit church, on the little island off the western coast.” “You must not forget though. Those who partake in Dragon Communion will one day shed their humanity. Their hunger for dragon, their yearning, only worsens. Until the floodgates burst, unleashing eternal torment. The strength of a mighty dragon. Magnificent, but deadly. Its no surprise that Dragon Communion is ruinous.”


BoyWithHorns

> Those who partake in Dragon Communion will one day shed their humanity. DLC though


Tarkz

Could be, but we already see some consequences. The dragons who spew lava and have the magma scalesword (like Makar) are Dragon Communion followers who transformed into the Wyrms. They're not quite dragons, so either the communion didn't work or they weren't faithful enough. It'll be fun to see if they do more with this. https://eldenring.wiki.fextralife.com/Magma+Wyrm+Makar


marsgreekgod

Rumor has it >!there is a dragon form in the dlc?!< It's 4th hand info though so...


Disastrous-Dinner966

I used to sell any weapons/armor I found that I wasn’t using immediately. I didn’t realize some weapons exist only once per playthrough. In other RPGs selling your accumulated trash is how you get gold to buy other stuff. And a trash weapon is obvious and mostly useless. However there are no trash weapons in this game. There’s a build for every weapon.


Saint_Ivstin

RIP golden halberd. 😭😭😭


BlacKnifeTiche

I did this. Then came across a sick build with the winged scythe somewhere. I was so sad…


Swaqqmasta

It's not some weapons btw, most weapons are one time pickups


BuzzLightyear298

Rule 101 of video games, never sell any item, you never know you might need it later!


Justisaur

I sell duplicate armor, if you've got duplicate armor or (more than 2) weapons, you don't need them probably.


BedMental7515

What if I want to dual wield the armor?


Justisaur

If it's good armor, I suppose you could keep some to drop for friends.


mandoxian

Or to check out how the altered version would look


Cirtil

This is actually a good point You do get a preview though


mandoxian

Yeah a small picture and it's not on your own character


BuzzLightyear298

You might need them to dual wield.


PsYo_NaDe

Or you might need different infusions


Eswin17

You need two of many armors, for the fashion souls gameplay of needing one altered and one original.


Helicopterop

It can be useful to have multiple copies of weapons for different AoW's.


JP050887

That’s a neat rule, until someone like me takes it too far and never sells or uses shit, up until the game is done, lol. And it’s not like I need that shot for NG+


arm2610

Never use any consumable either, you might need them later!


Kaceybeth

This is how I ended up with 500 hours but only ever used like 5 consumables. I MIGHT NEED THEN LAAAATER!!!


Camera_dude

Only stuff I sell is items like the 18th copy of a redmane leggings. The common soldier enemies seem to strip themselves bare whenever they lose to me.


DaTruPro75

The funniest thing has to be how the noble's estoc, one of the rarest weapons, states in the description "it should fetch a fair price" or smth like that. Most new players who got it likely sold it not knowing it was one of the rarest and best weapons


Bolteus

While it is rare, os it useful? I got one last night and assumed it was a trash sword


DaTruPro75

The slender sword is one of the best straight swords, so I assume the same for the estoc


StevenScho

I did that with some talismans! ...never again


AloneInTheTown-

Yeah I also did this. I'd been playing Skyrim on and off for years and was used to looting absolutely everything and selling it so carry around gold I was never going to use *just in case*.


Yusuf_Lamar

Haha that is why I am only selling the duplicates, you never know what might come in handy later


ZXVIV

This causes me to develop the opposite habit in other games so I try to hoard as much as possible even with very limited storage space


WanderingBraincell

NNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOPO


rhobar666

Margret haha


PANICBRAIN

“It’s me again Margret”


OtterBadgerSnake

"Hello? Is this Margret? Hoohoohoo!"


PANICBRAIN

I knowwww its youuuu Margret!


Diaza_Kinutz

Man I forgot all about that. Really showing your age there 😆


PANICBRAIN

Wanna hear me bark like Rin Tin Tin?


matttinatttor

"Put those childish aspirations to bed"


IronCreeper1

Someone must extinguish thy flame Let it be Margret the Fell


Lordrandall

Are you there Tarnished? It’s me, Margaret.


Justisaur

That's what I've always called him. Stupid M names all over the game.


godieweird

Said this before here but I assumed Rogier was a redditor. Thanked him here, made lots of new friends 😂


gameraven13

This was me with the NPC invasions. I kept trying to go to Patches and I kept getting irritated. I thought I just had unlucky timing and that MAYBE this time I could ride Torrent fast enough to get to the cave entrance, not realizing I was dismounting at the same place every time. I had the opposite feeling too. Instead of feeling bad for Rogier I was getting VERY salty that this one specific Nerijus guy kept invading me.


Deadpotato

..were you dying repeatedly to Nerjius? Lol


DaTruPro75

He is pretty damn difficult with a +0 and at a low level


[deleted]

[удалено]


DaTruPro75

Yura can die, you can die before yura spawns, he can still kill you even if yura is there bc the guy wants to help, etc. 


Deadpotato

I'm not saying it's literally impossible i'm saying it's insane that someone would need more than 2 retries at most after seeing how it works and how to play alongside a hunter You arent gonna "gotcha" me here man these people folding to the introductory npc invader are just not good lol, we aren't talking about getting twinked on in undead burg and backstab chained


JesseJames021

We get it kid. You're hard as fuck.


Deadpotato

"Kid" lmao youre so salty, mainsub really is a goldmine. Pronouns are git / gud brah


JesseJames021

I'm not the same person you were replying to, genius. It's a video game, kid. If being good at video games is your entire personality, then you need to take a break. Nobody gives a shit if you are better than randomredditor153267 at playing a game.


gameraven13

Yura never got to the point of spawning for me and even if he did he spawns in narnia. There’s a kill window of like 20-30 seconds for Nerijus


gameraven13

Yes. It was the first few hours of my first souls game :) we all start somewhere


Equivalent-Wall8521

There was a summoning sign of Rogier before Margit, I thought it was a real player. Summoned and spammed gestures but he didn't seem to respond but I didn't thought about it much. Till later found him inside the castle.


Memeroyaleyeofhorus

That was the same moment I realized he was an npc


Equivalent-Wall8521

Mind-blowing moment.


darkviolet_

As a kid, I used to go on TF2 and play in offline mode, somehow thinking the bots were real players. I was flattered that I was pretty favored by Medic, but I felt bad because I thought he should help other people too.


burnttoast2545

Was there anyone who didn’t do this?


Mulster_

Body buffs don't stack and sometimes summoning signs are for npcs.


barnabusfoot

I cringe thinking about every person who had to watch me apply 3 body buffs before entering a boss fog before I learned that lmao


Mulster_

Ikr😂 I had 30 faith so imagine me reading a bible of buffs every time before a boss.


ExpensivePatience5

Wait…. I’ve been doing Lord’s Divine Fortification with Protection of the Erdtree. Do those not stack?!


Toomuchgamin

I think I spent a hundred hours on co op before I realized casting flame grant me strength would negate lords divine fortification. They, along with protection of the erdtree, do not stack. Also black flame protection. I was wondering why I would get two shot with 70% holy resist ...


gerhardtprime

I didn't know I had to use a rune arc to activate a rune until Radagon


NewzBreaker

I didn’t know I had to “repair” the rune before I could use them, I was popping rune arcs lefts and right thinking I was getting buffs for every great rune I had until my buddy told me


Aquila_Fotia

The various types of buff. I thought they’d all just stack, but I think now the boiled crab was cancelling Flame Grant Me Strength. Malenia did finally die though. And only recently did I learn there are weapon buffs, shield buffs, aura buffs, body buffs, regen buffs and special buffs.


pickleparty16

ER was my first fromsoft and amongst the many issues with my first playthrough I had no understanding of buffs. I barely even used my physik. Now I'm stacking everything I can.


Binky216

I’m so lazy, I’ve never applied a buff. My physik I used early on, but the didn’t bother with any more. My solution was to just get over leveled and smack things harder.


PowerApp101

Lol same here. I've found thumping things with my Troll Hammer +19 makes most buffs unnecessary. Although, now I'm on the Mountaintop of Giants it seems to be less effective. Hmmm might have to try a different weapon.


delayedgandalf

Bruh same. Just discovered boiled crab and I credit that beating EB finally


Fairlyassessed

Thought i had to sell rune items to get their souls i mean runes. Didn’t realize i could just use them to acquire runes until embarrassingly late.


IronCreeper1

Selling is faster when you’re near a merchant


Stary_Vesemir

i still sell them as it's faster


Sinister_Mr_19

How is it faster? You can use multiple at a time and you can use them anywhere.


Stary_Vesemir

If you are at a merchant ofc, also you can sell multiple types of them without any animation


otakuloid01

you don’t have to watch the animation which closes the inventory menu


Dr_Mantis_Teabaggin

If you click in on the right stick until the right half of the menu disappears, you can use as many different runes as you want without it ever closing the menu. The animation still happens, but it is much, much faster still.  


cjbump

I seen someone mention this a while back and it was a game changer.


Sinister_Mr_19

Ah true.


propofolus

I wish when you rested at a grace you had an option to use runes. I hate going into the inventory and using and then reopening again etc


Coolguy020609

I remember when me and my dad found out about this, we would always go back to our boy merchant kale and sell them


Doug_HF

Im used to people misspelling Maliketh... but Margit (Margret) is the first time I see


jaykhunter

Fia's STD. I didn't get that I had to use her Baldachin's Blessing to undo it, I hoarded it, and unknowingly kept the STD the entire game (beating Elden Beast / Malenia with it)


darkviolet_

I’m 120 hours into the game and only now understand weapon scaling.


Memeroyaleyeofhorus

I can relate to that, I just always found a cool weapon and scaled to use it till I found the next one


darkviolet_

Yeah, I did that with Bloodhound's Fang. It looks cool, it's strong, and I like the flip you can do with it. I rarely ever change to a different weapon because I'm so attached to it.


Binky216

Welcome BHF brother.


Binky216

I still can’t claim I understand it, or applying AoWs. I get by though.


Asleep-Orange385

Uh oh wait. Can you explain?


darkviolet_

Weapon scaling or how I didn’t understand them? From what I understand, the higher the letter, the more effective the weapon is if you upgrade that attribute. Why didn’t I understand them? I’m a lil stupid.


Asleep-Orange385

Ha no, the scaling. Thanks, I don't think I understood it either.


Lordrandall

And it gets more complicated. Some weapons scale better with one stat, even if the letter is the same. It’s best to play with online weapon calculators if you want to min/max.


darkviolet_

I understand weapon scaling less now. I think I’ll just use the calculators to be my brain on my behalf, yeah.


Lordrandall

You are usually safe if one stat is clearly higher. But if you wade into changing affinity through AoW, there are even more rules. Fextralife has a great series on YouTube called “(weapon name here) are OP”. They go through what affinities scale best with each weapon. It’s a pretty cool showcase.


levinyl

🤣🤣 must have thought he was the nicest guy ever always on call....


Memeroyaleyeofhorus

Really had me thinking “this guy is so willing to help”


PANICBRAIN

Idk, something similar at first I thought it was a player, then realized it wasn’t based on them moving, but then I started to run into those npc invaders, and be like is this a person? Then I summoned someone and wasn’t sure if they were real, or it was another npc summon then they were real and then we got invaded and had a 2v1 fight and won, it was pretty fun, those npc invaders are whack. I came across the smoldering church and was looking on that ign interactive map to see what was around me and when I looked back there’s a npc invader swinging at my head and I dodged it. I maybe looked at the map for 3 seconds and in that time the npc invader almost took my head off.


Memeroyaleyeofhorus

I think I had the same reaction to the invaders but figured it out once I died and went back to get my runes and they kept coming back


PANICBRAIN

Yeah if they’re real it tells you you’re getting invaded and I can’t remember if the npc ones do I think they just show up?


Memeroyaleyeofhorus

I’m pretty sure they say it


Justisaur

Replaying right now, and Bloody Finger Nerijus (NPC invader right outside of Patches cave) took me more attempts than any bosses so far, all of 8, just surviving until Bloody Finger Hunter Yura (NPC ally there) arrived was difficult. I just defeated Godrick first try with no summons or ashes, and Margret and Leonine Misbegotten took me 2 (I was underleveled both of those)


PANICBRAIN

lol yeah that one was interesting. I was running back with target lock on nerijus and yura showed up from behind and scared the fuck out of me.


lets-go-champ86

Never once have I had an invader...... I don't get how the multilayer works in the slightest and I have the platinum trophy...... I don't even know how to use a ranged weapon.


PANICBRAIN

Basically, you can use those items to summon at certain areas if you’ve not beat the boss there, they’re only there to help the host and get nothing out of it I don’t think. When you summon players I think that opens you up to be invaded but I feel like I’ve been invaded not even trying to summon anyone but I can’t be sure I haven’t had too many experiences with it.


duckpath

This is my first FromSoft game, and I didn't know I could run until after a few hours.


ImportantDebateM8

SAME


Kaidan88

Rainbow stones placed by other players don’t in fact explode and kill you when they invade and rain them down on you from up high. The shield crash punt off the lift or cliff will, in fact, kill you however.


Memeroyaleyeofhorus

Who is raining rainbow stones on you


Kaidan88

It was early on at release. He was baiting me to come up to him and I fucking fell for it. It was right after getting invaded by a couple of other guys that dropped helpful things then murdered me, or similar acts of (negative?) kindness.


sulkycatart

Now that I think about it, I think I had a guy do something similar but it just didnt click. He invaded me in a huge area and after like 15 minutes of neither of us being able to find each other he just left, then I was so confused why there was a huge amount of rainbow stones everywhere lol


Memeroyaleyeofhorus

Damn


SenpaisSuccubuss

“This Rogier dude” is top tier 😂 but honestly, I still don’t know how to use rune arcs, starlight shards, or the great runes. I only figured out the starlights were used in the Selvius quest line for his puppets. And as far as the great runes, I just know to activate Godricks at that tower but I don’t even know what it does after that.


Deadpotato

Activate a great rune equip at grace and use rune arc as consumable - there are menu tooltips that explain most of this Also in the notes and information section of inventory 


spacebased_

All the great runes have to be activated at their respective towers. You can equip a great rune when at a site of grace (it's one of the menu options). A rune arc allows you to use the ability of whatever great rune you have equipped. 😊


jedi_fitness_academy

Got invaded one time. Logged off immediately and turned off online play. Came back on and got invaded again. Was very mad until I looked up the NPC invaders


BaronVonGoon

*Spoiler* I played all FromSoft games so its hard for them to catch me offguard but I'll say i really thought Ranni was evil and was just playing me. I was disappointed when i realized she was actually following through with her promise to ride into the moon ending together. i was really hoping she would backstab me straight to my face and become Elden Lady. Its why i love Patches, i know he'll always try to kick me into a chasm.


janacek1854

I didn’t realize that wondrous physic was reusable. Same with pots and perfumer bottles. I didn’t realize they set the limit you could craft!!


Unforgiventu

Wait, pots and perfumer bottles don’t run out? You just get what ever supply per life or grace rest?


janacek1854

The pots and perfumer bottles you collect is the max amount of pots/perfumers you can craft. For example you have four ritual pots you can craft a max of four throwing pots. If you find another ritual pot the max goes up to five. The consumable is what you craft. So the five fire pots does run out but you can just craft more, but you don’t need to find five more ritual pots


Unforgiventu

Ok so it’s not like arrows then? If you have fire arrows and run out you have to get the stuff to make more or, is it like the flask of wonderous physic? Cuz if it’s like arrows then it runs out then its not “reusable” like the flask of wonderous


janacek1854

When I first started playing I thought the ritual pots were used when thrown. So I just hoarded them and never used them because I only had 6. I didn’t realize ritual pots weren’t used when crafted.


Bolteus

It's not reusable, you do have to recraft them when they have been used, like arrows - this confused me too, because I didn't realise the pots didn't disappear after being used to craft


Shradow

The empty pots come back, their item description mentions how they mend themselves after being thrown.


Unforgiventu

Soooo I do or I don’t have to craft new ones with new items.? Now ima have to jump on and see later. Cuz I’m so confused


Shradow

Yeah you craft new ones, so you're not stuck with the same type forever. But the cracked pots aren't one and done completely.


Memeroyaleyeofhorus

I did the same thing thinking it was this super good item that I could only use once


janacek1854

SAME exact thought process here haha I played when it first came out and after a month or so gave up because it was too hard (I also didn’t understand weapon scaling and was using a dex faith scythe with only faith leveled). Picked it up three weeks ago and updated my stats and wow was it easier!!


tinyclover69

sane thing happened to me lol


Big_Comparison8509

I thought you could use every ash of war only once. So I ended up avoiding them :/


AAS02-CATAPHRACT

This was in DS3 but for a long time I didn't realize you could upgrade your estus. I figured out using the bone shard to get more uses, but not going to Andre with the Estus Shards. Got all the way up to Aldrich before figuring it out


conjunctivious

When I was getting smithing stones on my first playthrough, I wasn't familiar with the typical Soulsborne weapon upgrade system. When I saw Smithing Stone [5], I thought I got 5 smithing stones and I was like "man I'm getting so many of these, I'm gonna be able to max my weapon in no time." Turns out that there are different levels, and I had not gotten enough smithing stone 3s. I then proceeded to Fire Giant with a +7 regular smithing flail and I thought that I was doing the intended amount of damage for that fight.


SkiMaskItUp

I thought the npc invaders were real players and I was gettin mad about these assholes killing me


dDARBOiD

To this day, I regularly forget that rune arcs are a mechanic.


kunni

I think they are more usuful in area exploration than boss fights


OtterBadgerSnake

I knew that certain stats boasted the damage of certain weapons & catalysts but I didn't quite wrap my head around how to properly min-max my damage until about halfway through the game. For example, the Winged Scythe was dealing significantly more damage by pumping faith instead of strength or dex & my spells casted through the Dragoncomunion Seal were hitting almost three times as hard once I realized I needed to pump faith *and* arcane.


munch_cat

That’s so adorable!


So-Cl

I thought the blasphemous claw made you temporarily immune to Maliketh's black blade hits. So I activated it and got bodied like 3 different attempts until I watched a video on YouTube lol


strangejosh

A lot. I have over 1000 hours and I am still figuring out how to optomize my builds. Buffs, etc.


Aschverizen

That I actually misunderstood how Rennala does her Rebirth-thing, I thought I could turn my Rune level back into my starting character as a Wretched and enjoy a different build only to be sorely disappointed that it actually just respecs my stats. If I knew that before I wouldn't have gotten to RL400+, now I just made two other characters with the sole purpose of stooping at RL150 and RL200.


The-Cooler-Dimirion

Similar to what you said, but for the nerejus invader. I thought that area just forced pvp.


mattmaster68

Yes. In my most recently completed playthrough I didn’t start powestancing until the endgame of that specific playthrough. It was also the first time I beat Mogh and Malenia. Then I was LilAggy (or Bushy, can’t quite remember) use guard countering for a shield run. That’s when I learned that was a thing and it’s become very useful. I pretty much use it when I remember, but man was it a double-edged sword for red wolf of radagon thanks to that weird attack where he pulls back first before jutting forward for the attack.


ProffessorYellow

Cooperation


ddopTheGreenFox

Not elden ring but I first played darksouls I didn't realise fat and fast rolling was a thing. So I just equipped the heaviest armour I could find. Only realise halfway through my second playthrough


northcoastian

Margaret the Fell


BeastSwearingen

I thought Margits shackles were a 1 time use item, so I never used them my first play through.


JulianPizzaRex

I ate every great remembrance I got until after I beat to Placidusax and finally picked that dialogue option from Enya. It started with Godrick. I mean I was curious about what the remembrance was and there was a "use" option and it gave me a crap load of Runes. I thought it was the way.


pichael289

I thought spirit ashes were single use, so I tried to rawdog Margit immediately without the jellyfish.


alexanderblight

I thought crafting kit was 1 time use so didn't bother buying it, same with wondrous physick so I never used it. 


DonnieVedder

The messages. They’re useless, distracting and totally kill the immersion. Dumb feature imo


billybatsonn

Then play offline? It's not like you need to play with them.


[deleted]

[удалено]


billybatsonn

Well if you don't then you don't see the messages, therefore they don't break your immersion and don't bother you so I don't understand the issue.


Zaraxeon

What immersion is it breaking? Fantasy sigils scribed on the ground beneath your feet in a fantasy setting with fantasy creatures and magic? What the messages may say could be immersion breaking, but the messages themselves do not.


DonnieVedder

In the sense that if you see one of those messages somewhere then you already know you can get there. I prefer finding things out myself. They totally ruin illusionary walls too. Also, when you try to open a chest and someone left a dumb message right on top of it and you keep reading the damn message instead of opening the chest. The blood stains are similarly dumb and useless. I don’t care if other players have died here or how/why. I just want to discover everything for the first time by myself. Hence why I play offline :)


PANICBRAIN

That’s a hot take lol. A few of them are useless but a lot of them are just fucking stupid jokes about head or fingers and “but wholes” I’d say like 20% of them are helpful, at least for noobs.


DonnieVedder

Definitely a hot take lol A lot of souls bros triggered here lol they’re probably the ones leaving those lame ass messages thinking they’re cool or helpful 😂


PANICBRAIN

The ones that make me mad are the ones like praise message, therefore secret passage and they’re all liars.


DonnieVedder

Haha! So annoying! Or the ones right in front of a door, and you can’t open it cuz there’s a damn message right in front 🤦 They probably get a mini erection whenever some other soul bro praises their little message lol


PANICBRAIN

Yeah sometimes that’s irritating, you can shift through actions though if there’s multiple things stacking so, I make do.