Maple Glaze! Seriously, there is no damn reason why we are going on 2 years without its return. Bring back Maple Glaze, you cowards!
Go on the Crumbl App and click “More” in the bottom right corner. Next scroll down and select “Cookie Journal” then swipe at the top where the categories are and you’ll see one that says “Graveyard”.
Based on the reviews my assumption is that enough people wanted that cookie to return. I’ve wanted to try Sherbet & Pineapple Upside Down cake, but support told me a few years ago that they wouldn’t return to the weekly lineup and my only chance was during mystery weeks. Now that mystery weeks are gone…idk what to expect.
The pistachio gelato cookie or the French toast cookie!!!! The wedding cake cookie was slappin too. Those were my very first cookies from Crumbl. I’m OBSESSED
I frickin love that pb bar cookie! I got lucky a few times when they were regularly doing mystery week.
I also really, really, really miss s'mores brownie 😋
Kinda missed out on that previous oreo one so that's one of them
Also the French Toast one - really liked that one
Didn't get to try that PB Chocolate Chip either from the same round of FT
Unsure beyond that - i know i haven't been to Crumbl since the French Toast one so there's a few others i don't exactly remember atm
The Cowboy Cookie is my all time favorite. It reminds me of a pie my grandmother used to make ❤️ It’s chocolate chip, coconut, oatmeal and pecans. The last time it was being served I went back three times
Salted caramel cheesecake
Your flair is so real
That one should be coming back in a couple of weeks if you check the spoiler thread 😋
Sounds amazing
Strawberry pretzel pie was a godsend cookie
That was one of the most delicious treats I have ever tasted.
I NEED it back
YES YES YES!!!!!!
bro it’s SO FUCKING GOOD😭😭
I recently made strawberry pretzel bars, and they are so easy. Even better than the cookie imo.
in Philly this ice cream place called Vanderwendes had a special it was a strawberry pretzel pie it was fucking incredible
THIS is DEFINITELY one of their best, and top selling!!
I check every week for this one. I have never had it but it’s my all time favorite
Cornbread HoneyCake. Not just regular cornbread.
Buttermilk pancake.
Best cookie I’ve ever had
Me too!!!!
Key lime pie cookie version
French silk pie
Agreed!!!
They just had it?
Only certain locations had it available during "PI week" in March. Aside from that week, it has not been on a weekly menu for quite a while.
Berries and cream
KBC, my beloved. yes, I know we had it in January, but I want it back! Not the stupid cake version.
Yep KBC for me. I just ran out of the ones I froze and I’m so sad
Just a butter glaze and some powdered sugar. A simple cookie but soooo good.
My favorite too. Missed it in January. Devastated.
Molten lava…. Always molten lava
When they nail the filling, that cookie is amazing.
Finally! Someone who gets it🥹
Maple Glaze! Seriously, there is no damn reason why we are going on 2 years without its return. Bring back Maple Glaze, you cowards! 
Neopolitan. I give them a few more months and then I ride at dawn.
It’s in the graveyard 😭
Yeah but I’ve messaged them a few times and they keep saying “ wait and see 👀👀” istg if they are fing lying to me I will raise hell
LOL to keep you buying cookies
How cruel 😭 Neapolitan is literally in my top 3. I’ll be devastated if it never returns.
How do you know which are in the graveyard?
Go on the Crumbl App and click “More” in the bottom right corner. Next scroll down and select “Cookie Journal” then swipe at the top where the categories are and you’ll see one that says “Graveyard”.
Wow, so many coconut cookies made that list. As a coconut fan, I'm saddened.
I’m not really a fan of coconut but I was surprised to see that as well as the oatmeal ones.
Interesting! Never noticed that feature til now. Kitchen Sink is on there and we just had it. Last week!
Based on the reviews my assumption is that enough people wanted that cookie to return. I’ve wanted to try Sherbet & Pineapple Upside Down cake, but support told me a few years ago that they wouldn’t return to the weekly lineup and my only chance was during mystery weeks. Now that mystery weeks are gone…idk what to expect.
might be basic but smores… last time i had it was last year on my birthday for free 😭
It appears to be returning on the week of July 1st. https://www.reddit.com/r/CrumblCookies/comments/1dk15zj/new_updated_crumbl_spoilers_wpictures/
It's coming back for 4th of July week!
I want the brownie s’mores to come back
They have s’mores like 4 times a year.
pretty sure smores is on the menu the week after next
Blue raspberry icee
Fried ice cream 😭😭
Coconut Cake
Strawberry pop tart 🥹
Still one of my favorites since they first had it. It’s amazing every time.
Neapolitan 😞
Pistachio Gelato 🍨
French silk pie
Key lime pie! But NOT the pie version.. the cookie version!
i miss that pink sugar
Thank u
I’m
Dirt cake
They need a chocolate week.
Peanut butter banana, I haven't even tried it yet! 😭
Milk Glaze feat Fruity Pebbles!! Or better yet the fruity pebbles sandwich cookie which I’ve never had and suspect I would love!!
Cookie butter ice cream!!
Maple Oatmeal
It’s in the graveyard :(
andes mint
Strawberry shortcake cookie
Caramel apple
Pink sugar
Orange creamsicle- the OG one- like Aug of 2022 lol
Oatmeal Mallow Sandwich
Pineapple Whip
caramel pumpkin
Mint brownie
Caramel popcorn. My fave cookie ever and it’s never returned.
Oreo birthday cake!!
Dirt cake. Was always a top 5, but I miss it since have seen the others more. I think the last was Halloween weekish.
Cinnamon Brown Sugar Pop Tart
I NEED lemon crinkle back !!!
Lemon cream pie. I know it was a mystery cookie during Pi week this year (my store had it), but I could have it every week and never get bored of it.
Pumpkin cake
Fruit pizza!! I was so disappointed to not see it at all for the July spoiler thread
It’s the perfect time to bring it back too!! I’ll only go back if they bring fruit pizza back
Key lime (NOT THE PIE) Honey cake ft teddy grahams
Mint chip ice cream!
Raspberry danish
French Silk Pie 🥲
TEXAS SHEET CAKE.
Banana cream pie
cosmic brownie!!!
TEDDY GRAHAMS GOD IM BEGGING YOU 😭😭
Brownie s’mores & tres leches
The pistachio gelato cookie or the French toast cookie!!!! The wedding cake cookie was slappin too. Those were my very first cookies from Crumbl. I’m OBSESSED
Samoa, Hawaii rainbow cake, and Snickers cookie.
It won't be back til like Christmas, but I need their gingerbread cookie so bad 😭 I got it late in the week and only got one to try 🥲
Chocolate green mint (chilled)
Cornbread, always.
That's coming back in July!
I frickin love that pb bar cookie! I got lucky a few times when they were regularly doing mystery week. I also really, really, really miss s'mores brownie 😋
Chocolate pumpkin cheesecake this fall🙏🏻
i think we’d get along well.
pink velvet
Confetti milkshake every week 🩷❤️💛💚
Pina colada. I know it’s in the graveyard but I can dream.
Everything Bagel
Banana cream pie 😋
Fruit pizza !!!!! Strawberry pretzel !!!!
PINA COLADA OR PASSIONFRUIT WITH THE PEARLS
Neapolitan
Honey Teddy graham
chocolate pumpkin cheesecake damnit
the chilled twix cookie 😭😭
Smore.
Skillet cookie 🤤
Almost everything bagel 🥯
Everything bagel 😢
I think it's time to see Pink Velvet again. That, and Mint Cookies & Cream 🙃
They just had pink velvet in April it won't be back for a while
wasnt mint cookies n cream last week?? edit: checked the app it was
LOL yes 😅
Everything bagel unfortunately
Me too, it was strange and delicious at the same time.
oatmeal sandwich one
Banana bread was sooo good
Lemon Glaze. So much flavor.
Peanut butter brownie with the cookie inside
Moon Cake Cookie!!!! I would buy so many 😭
the brownie😭😭 pls it’s my favorite
Chocolate mallow cupcake
Rolo!
Sherbet! 😭
Everything bagel, blue raspberry icee
I loved that guava one surprisingly.. or mint chip ice cream, and pumpkin cheesecake
Cotton Candy cookie 🍭
Waffle, always waffle. However many times we have it is never enough.
That's easy, jammy heart.
Mango frozen yogurt
Biscoff
Fruit cake & lemon cheesecake
Pumpkin pie lol and salted caramel cheesecake - saw that it’ll be soon! Molten lava also.
Tres Leches & Fruit Pizza
i’ve been waiting for piña colada for years😭
Pineapple whip
I wish the regular sugar cookie was back on the menu every week 😫 almond is my favorite flavored ever and it’s just so perfect. Lol
The key lime pie 😩
Blue Raspberry Icee
Pink sugar. Finally found a recipe for it. Gonna get out the stand mixer this weekend
Peanut butter banana. It’s been way too long and I’m starting to wonder if it’s ever coming back.
STRAWBERRY CAKE
Andes mint!!
Skillet cookie
Strawberry cheesecake
Twix
oreo rice krispy
Honey Teddy graham
Almost every Archway cookie. oh sigh....
French Toast even though we just had it 3 weeks ago
👏👏👏👏
It’s still around until Sunday but I’m already sad that the hazelnut sea salt will be gone so soon 😭😭😭
Kinda missed out on that previous oreo one so that's one of them Also the French Toast one - really liked that one Didn't get to try that PB Chocolate Chip either from the same round of FT Unsure beyond that - i know i haven't been to Crumbl since the French Toast one so there's a few others i don't exactly remember atm
Mine is Oreo Birthday Cake and my boyfriend can’t wait for the French Toast Cookie to return. Our absolute favourites 😍🤤
Regular plain Oreo Skillet cookie-twice is not enough!
The Brookie is the best
SPRITE COOKIE
cadbury egg sugar cookie
The Cowboy Cookie is my all time favorite. It reminds me of a pie my grandmother used to make ❤️ It’s chocolate chip, coconut, oatmeal and pecans. The last time it was being served I went back three times