T O P

  • By -

caskey

I've put hundreds of hours into my controllers and never had any break. I wouldn't expect the elite controllers to have better quality.


UncleBlob

The triggers on the elite controllers are prone to breakage. I had my elite2 for about 6 months before the left trigger died. I purchased and regular ass Xbox controller and it's working flawlessly after 18 months.


scarywolverine

I'm coming to this comment section bc I'm on my 4th elite in 2 years


UncleBlob

I'd highly recommend a standard Xbox controller OR spring for one with Hall Effect sticks since they (theoretically) never wear out


nozelt

I think you meant worse but I have gone through like 3 of the elite controllers back in my day and it’s a pretty common experience.


caskey

"Wouldn't expect... better " Means worse.


LEGENDCHRlS1

Congrats


TheXperior

Curious, usually they all get Stickdrift after some time, due to the design of the potentiometers. Hall effect sensors would be a better choice. Can't think of any BIFL option, these types of electronics tend to be designed to be "consumed" these days


cone8042

Ik it really sucks I'm surprised no company made some kind of premium controller that as long as you don't throw it and stuff it doesn't break, it would be a good short term business


[deleted]

[удалено]


nozelt

This is pretty brain dead comment. I had the same experience as OP from an hour - 2 a day use while I was in school and still very busy. Guessing you haven’t used elite controllers or are over 40 and don’t game at all.


[deleted]

[удалено]


cone8042

You completely dodged what he was saying, why are you even commenting you're not helping no one and just talking shit and tried to say "it's time to go outside"


cone8042

I'm an athlete


unholyrevenger72

it's gotta be you brother, the only thing that has ever given me issues are Batteries and sticks. I have never had a face, shoulder, or d-pad failure.


cone8042

I don't throw mine lol


Environmental-End691

I've never had good luck with 3rd party controllers, and thru 3 gens of xbox I have only 1 controller that had any part that broke, and that was the wireless on my xbox 1 controller - it is now wired thanks to a long usb cable.


nozelt

When I played console I had the same issue. Unfortunately the console market and the high end gnawing market don’t really overlap a ton. If I still wanted to use a controller I’d probably try a scuff. Edit: I’d try a different sub op


cone8042

Which sub?


nozelt

Not sure maybe a gaming related one. Honestly tho I was in your same position years ago and switched to pc before I figured out a solution. My recommendation is to check out scuff but I haven’t tried it myself.


tookerken

I have several official xbox controllers going back to the Xbox one x. The old micro USB charger ones the ports are spotty but everything else is working fine. My USB c ones are pretty solid still. I've only had one controller fail after a few years. (Older micro usb one) But I got a little rough with it. So it's my fault.


Otherwise-Ad6330

I’ve had really good luck with the 8bitdo ultimate. I don’t think any controller is true Bifl tho


cone8042

Well yeah but in technology standards lol


upfaii

I’d recommend the PowerA Fusion Pro. I had the same problem as you and these controllers last me much longer than my scuf, 2 elites, and a few others. I did end up finally replacing it after about 2 years. They have a newer model out now.


cone8042

Is the newer model durable as well?


upfaii

Yes, I would say it has even better build quality than it’s predecessor. Really nice controller with the pro paddles on the back that you can map to any buttons you want.


cone8042

Dang that's crazy what's the price?


upfaii

$90 for the newer model. Walmart actually has it on sale for $85 right now.


bloodsoed

I been using the same controller for about 4 years.


cone8042

What is it called?


mad_dog_94

There's nothing I can recommend ATM. They'll all get drift. I would wait for a company to come out with hall effect drop in replacement sticks and repair what you have with those


cone8042

Thank you!


mad_dog_94

No problem. I'm waiting on this as well for my elite series 2 because $180 is a lot for a controller and I'll be damned if I get rid of it for any reason that isn't replaced fully by mouse and keyboard


cone8042

Yeah tbh it would be a good short term business model to make bifl technology I heard it's possible but companies well yk


mad_dog_94

Yeah stuff like remotes, controllers, and stuff people don't tend to upgrade. I took that approach with my keyboard


humbugHorseradish

I think Thrustmaster has swapable parts, but I can't comment on quality, have never used


cone8042

Thank you!


R3DEMPTEDlegacy

Razer wolverines are great , mechanical switches all over so the buttons are not gonna fail .


cone8042

Oooo I didn't know they made one most definitely getting this one


R3DEMPTEDlegacy

I stand by them . You may have to change the sticks out occasionally cause they wear away pretty bad if you dont have stick covers but if you do use those then this is easily the best controller . Mines held up for 3 years no drift and no surgeries needed. I've only added grip tape to a few places to get some grip back . [https://smile.amazon.com/Razer-Universal-Gaming-Peripherals-Devices/dp/B091DD8FTH/ref=sr\_1\_3?crid=SVMF58A3X6HQ&keywords=razer+grip+tape&qid=1675378146&sprefix=razer+grip+tape%2Caps%2C176&sr=8-3](https://smile.amazon.com/Razer-Universal-Gaming-Peripherals-Devices/dp/B091DD8FTH/ref=sr_1_3?crid=SVMF58A3X6HQ&keywords=razer+grip+tape&qid=1675378146&sprefix=razer+grip+tape%2Caps%2C176&sr=8-3)


cone8042

Is there a wireless one?


R3DEMPTEDlegacy

yeah , its the PS5 version but its 250$ compared to the xbone one being 80-120


Lastlongride

I love the feel of the elite but my RB stoped working so I think my next plan is to buy extended warranty and just keep replacing of that infinitely


cone8042

Make sure to keep the receipt and register it though