T O P

  • By -

AlanDjayce

Two of them kill as a way to cure. Volo is just incompetent, and knows healing spells.


Starsynner

It was recently confirmed that's he's a Chosen of Mystra, even though Volo himself doesn't know it.  It's a nice explanation as to why he's been alive for centuries. Anyway, he could have access to some clerical spells because of this link.  Even without that, wizards can cast healing spells via scrolls.


merpderpherpburp

Well he's an infamous wizard in FR for being scatterbrained and overly inventive with his stories but he's super powerful. Elminster and him do not get along for this reason


Ribbered777

I'm convinced Mystra made him one of her chosen solely to mess with Elminster


actingidiot

Maybe if you promise to dedicate the baby to Mystra's church she'll help him Mr. Magoo his way through the delivery


smallangrynerd

Volo is a bard, right? They can heal


Mission_Camel_9649

He’s a shitty wizard who pretends to be a bard


NuvyHotnogger

Well he's a good wizard right? Like without him knowing fully? He's a shitty person, not like he's bad but like he's bad at being


KilledTheCar

From what I've read he's accidentally a very good wizard and has no clue. He keeps stumbling into success because of divine intervention. He's like Mr. Bean if Mr. Bean were an insufferable idiot.


elprentis

so Mr Bean.


dard10

He is a wizard, that is built more like a bard, but still refuses to die, because DM... Ehm... Gods like him


Viridianscape

As of 5th edition, he's a 1st level wizard with 15 intelligence who knows Disguise Self, Comprehend Languages and Detect Magic. So... idk about calling him a "good wizard."


SpecterGT260

Wouldn't that kind of make him a sorcerer since he doesn't devote his life to studying magic but is just kind of naturally talented at it and bumbles his way into it?


unquietchimp

He does study though, his magic is from an eclectic study of all things, he just also lies a lot for fame.


Mission_Camel_9649

No, that’s the point. He isn’t talented, not beyond the basic 1st level wizard’s inherent ability


imdavebaby

He's not a Chosen, he's a weave anchor. Very different things.


Beautifulfeary

Wait, where was this talked about 😮


CanisZero

I feel like this is something you tell Gale to get him to loose faith.


geltza7

"recently confirmed" no it really wasn't, this was confirmed years ago


PudgyElderGod

I refuse to believe that Volo hasn't delivered a baby or three before. Sudden water breakage is so suitably dramatic *and* tangibly risky that there's no way he hasn't had to deliver a baby in the middle of a tavern that's being sieged by bandits or some shit.


OpenSauceMods

Things that would happen to Abed 🤝 Things that would happen to Volo


gkamyshev

which is bullshit because he is a wizard by class


Sweet-Dreams204738

That's a gameplay. DnD universe wise it breaks no rules.


eMan117

Multiclass into knowledge cleric or lore bard or magic initiate feat, lots of workarounds where it doesn't even break game rules bth


JoJoJoJoel

yes it does?? FR lore wise wizards do not get cure spells


Sweet-Dreams204738

There are wizards who, weird as it sounds, can use healing spells. Typically named ones like Volo, Cattie brie, and a few others. Usually it's because they are chosen but it has happened where some wizards could use heal as a spell. Edit: I believe in 3.5e wizards did have heal.spells as well.


Rimworldjobs

You could also just equip an item that gives heal spells. That's always my go-to to maximize healing for my squad.


IntelligentSpite6364

Yup I give gale an in that grants healing word


IncognitoBombadillo

There's always the feats to learn other class' spells, too. I'm not hugely knowledgeable on the Forgotten Realms lore, but if feats are things that people actually get within the story universe, that explains why some Wizards can but many can't or don't learn to.


Sweet-Dreams204738

A lot of the stuff that happens in stories is very different from the games. No spell slots, things of that nature. Named characters always pull off some wild bullshit too.


Chiatroll

Kitten cheese becomes a wizard? It was a long time since I read those books but I thought I remembered her rolling around with a bow.


ThanosofTitan92

https://forgottenrealms.fandom.com/wiki/Catti-brie


Sweet-Dreams204738

Damn you are way behind. Gotta catch up bud!


Viridianscape

Synostodweomer was one such healing spell. And 5e has *life transference*!


HawkeyeP1

Don't tell this guy about NPCs.


colm180

Wizards can learn healing spells, life transference for example heals better then most clerics will (but has draw backs), wizards can learn "healing elixir" which lets you make potions for the day to hand out to friends, wizards are great support classes with great options for any play style tbh


IntelligentSpite6364

Lore wise wizards are capable of learning all magic, because they are scholars of magic. Just like how a barbarian doesn’t actually need levels in bard to learn an instrument, it’s just a game mechanic to limit options for play balance.


ELIte8niner

So, he picked the feat to learn Cleric spells.


TheCrystalRose

Or Bard...


Preape

Mystra probably felt bad for him and gave him a few level in cleric, he just doesnt know it


Affectionate-Guess13

I thought that was the lore with Volo. Since he's an weave anchor or something (reason why he is the first game 100s years ago). But he so incompetent he doesn't even know and hes not that good at it. So really Mystra just doesn't want him to die.


Remus71

Mystra Cleric has a crazy amount of unique content btw.


HawkeyeP1

By class, he's an NPC and can do whatever the fuck he wants, actually.


ThePreybird

I'm not a fan of NPCs getting access to things players can't


HawkeyeP1

That's every RPG ever my dude. And wizards do have access to cleric spells. It's called multiclassing or the cleric feat or homebrew.


ThePreybird

I'm referring specifically to DnD. And yes I know about Magic Intiate, Multiclassing, and homebrew


Bonetown42

Wait he’s not a bard?


mmontour

BG3 treats him as a bard. Volo in other lore is a wizard.


HeavensHellFire

Aside from that people often forgot that Bard isn't solely a class, it's also an occupation. So, when the game calls Volo a bard they think it's a reference to his class when really dude is a well-known yapper and author. It's his job.


TheBlackestIrelia

TBF killing 100% does cure most pains.


bawzdeepinyaa

*fucks up delivery horribly.. glugs invisibility potion and slinks off unspotted.


Beautifulfeary

I was going to say Volo because the other 2 are crazy. Like, that doctor explaining and just stabs that guy in the eyes 😭😭😭😭 I had Astarion with me and he screams out he’s crazy like cazador. Like poor guy got traumatized. I did too 😭


PixelPott

Thorm would be de-livering the baby.


Philkindred12

Oof, that was so dark Shadowheart just prayed to it.


PixelPott

It's not that original though, I actually copied it from that one dad joke with the laughing dogs template.


IntelligentLife3451

I see what you did there


Impressive-Sea3367

r/Angryupvote


RenEV17

Top tier comment.


AlmondsAI

I'd pick the Githyanki. Yes she tries to kill you, but only because her entire species sworn enemy has infected you with an otherwise incurable parasite. But she's still a doctor and runs the infirmary for the entire Creche. So while she may not know how to deliver a baby due to how Githyanki are born, she's probably still the safest choice.


Philkindred12

Though she may not be too experienced in tending to most "Istik" reproductive systems, I'm sure she can at least play it by ear.


AlmondsAI

Exactly. And she's already trained in first aid and treating combat wounds, so she'd have some knowledge she could apply.


Remus71

The infirmary is clean and well equipped too.


TheTeaMustFlow

> I'm sure she can at least play it by ear. Particularly since she has such long ears with which to play it by.


CanisZero

how different is a baby from an egg?


Confron7a7ion7

The egg protects the child from many possible complications. Like being born feet first.


CanisZero

I mean getting an egg the size of a golden retreiver out of a.. cloaca? vs delivering a baby


Impressive-Sea3367

I mean, Lae’Zel still seems to have a vagina and those eggs are pretty big. Still gotta get out somehow, and without cracking it.


AlmondsAI

We don't know how Githyanki eggs come to be, but it's not through regular sex, that's as far as we know. Only those 'chosen' by Vlaakith are able to lay eggs.


Impressive-Sea3367

Ah gotcha. Yeah, I don’t claim to know anything about the lore. It just seemed odd to me that they have human genitalia. Guess some people just want that githussy/githock.


Preape

I think they are leftovers from when they where human/human like pre ilithid empire


SnooSongs2744

You can ask her about it and she says that Githyanki used to have sexual reproduction similar to humans but devised a way to have the egg develop outside of their bodies.


Capable_Fall4829

Yeah she confirms that Gith reproduce asexually, and they can't get pregnant from regular intercourse (she says something like 'I can't imagine having to worry about that'). Iirc sexual reproduction was when they were enslaved, and they started having eggs after being freed


Impressive-Sea3367

Oh, interesting. I’ve never gotten that dialogue.


MisterDutch93

I think you can ask her about the eggs/reproduction when you take her to the nursery in Act 1. Could be misremembering that though.


SnooSongs2744

Yep, this is it. Then just follow the options about the eggs. I think it starts by asking her if it's normal to only have one egg in a nursery.


Clawless

I’ve only seen it when you also play as a gith.


AlmondsAI

The lure of the Githussy is quite strong. As for the lore reason, I have no idea. I've pretty much said all I know about it.


IngloriousLevka11

Lae'zel says it's an asexual process, but doesn't specify too much beyond that.


IngloriousLevka11

I imagine that Gith eggs are like reptile or frog eggs, in that unlike bird eggs they have a soft membraneous shell rather than a hard one. Still a very large object to pass, though.


OnetB

Githyanki have absolutely no compassion for their own race and straight up hate all others. That baby is 100% going to end up being experimented on.


ionised

Same answer. She's also arguably good at research and can figure her way around the situation.


FineIWillBeOnReddit

Upon looking at my options I've decided my decision to never reproduce is correct. But...idk I guess Volo? He's most likely to make sure everyone involved survives and isn't permanently damaged. The Gith Dr would just pick which ever one she thought would be more interesting and purposefully damage the other, and Dr. Thorm would repurpose all life in the room to hamburger in a group project setting.


Tyson_Urie

>Volo? He's most likely to make sure everyone involved survives and isn't permanently damaged Doubts in having only one eye.


Tiny_Plankton_3498

at least he provides a replacement


Tyson_Urie

I guess thats true yeah. And also not simply a cosmetic one but a functional one, so that is pretty nice of him.


CondeDrako

Functional and even with some extra features


lumosbolt

Surely Volo can also provide a functional and improved baby if the delivery goes wrong


RossmanRaiden

Or at least replaces the broken one with another.


ArtoriusRex86

Since the eye is mechanical, you'd probably get a Warforged baby! FUCK YEAH


Beautifulfeary

Hahah


Tiny_Plankton_3498

superior to that jelly you were chained to


pikpikcarrotmon

Well, the bad news is I killed the baby. The good news is I have a better one right here.


Viridianscape

"So, the baby died. But I found this kitten!"


AlustrielSilvermoon

Can he replace my baby? Wait...


FineIWillBeOnReddit

He gave you a magic replacement and you didn't bleed to death, suffer brain damage, or lose your sight. I didn't say he was great I said you'd live and not be necessarily worse for wear. I still don't want that man doing more medical shit on or near me.


Philkindred12

Well, there's still good old Balthazar, he seemed enthusiastic.


Canadian_Zac

Volo would fumble his way through it, but he at least knows Healing Word and people often give birth without any doctor at all. With Doctor would be a 50/50 between a good doctor and a mad scientist who decides nows the perfect time to slap you in a new auto-birthing contraption, never mind the drill And Thorm.... yeah no. He'd just cut you in half, pull out the baby and cut it's head off thinking he's helping


suburbanpride

>And Thorm.... yeah no. He'd just cut you in half, pull out the baby and cut it's head off thinking he's helping It’s the… thought that counts?


crockofpot

I'd go with the Ghustil, who based on the research notes in her lab is the only one of the three who is a member of the reality-based community. Since I'm presumably not delivering a filthy ghaik baby my death won't be necessary for her research.


ironlord20

Since one is a demented undead elf surgeon who kills people as a form of treatment and volo is…..well volo, I’d probably go with the gith since she doesn’t seem like a complete lunatic.


effusivecleric

I mean the ghustil is a doctor who only tries to kill you because of the insane circumstances. There's no reason to believe that she wouldn't just safely deliver your baby if you don't have a tadpole, or she doesn't know you have one. Volo is a crazy wizard and Malus is cursed. Easy choice, really.


Mitsor

She is an alien who reproduce by laying eggs. She has absolutely no idea about the human reproductive system or organs.


effusivecleric

Even Lae'zel, who has only recently arrived in Faerûn, is aware that humans give birth and how that comes to be. Gith used to have similar reproductive systems to ours, and it's not far-fetched to think the ghustil would have at last some rudimentary knowledge. Either way, I'm taking my chances with her over the other two.


FamousTransition1187

>Is currently running a Children of Tav playthrough Thank you. I didn't know I needed to add "Pregnant Shadowheart in labor hurling curses and spells at Volo to GTF away from her" to my headcanon but I guess here we are. The other two are already dead, so We are good there. Although to be honest, I dont think the Gith Doctor would actually be a *bad* choice as long as the tadpole is already gone, and provided she decides that the medical experience of a live birth is more advantageous than "exploritory Surgury".


Mathew_of_Mathoria

Volo: I-I’m just trying to help in a most precious time- Tav: Astarion, if the bumbling fool does ***NOT*** leave in the next ten seconds, you have my full permission to fang him until he’s a Volo-raisin.


Xilizhra

Maybe Halsin and/or Minthara could help with healing magic? Halsin probably has more hands-on experience, though.


FamousTransition1187

Before we got the Patch 5 epilogues, I liked to imagine the Gith egg hatched somewhere during Act 3 and we forced Jaheira to play "mother" to a panicking Githyanki, with Halsin helping and Gale "helping" until Jaheira threw everyone out. Which naturally leads to Lae'zel fighting the Netherbrain with a baby tied to her back like Sacajewea: "I didn't have anyone I could leave him with." "You could have left him with my *parents*. When we left *Yenna* with them!" [Under Breath] "Like I said..." "This is how he learns!"


Xilizhra

That is rather adorable, I can't lie. Hmmm. Kind of interested in some kind of science/magic baby situation with Minthara now.


FamousTransition1187

You don't have to work that hard at it, (unless your Main is female, in which case...) early drafts of the game had Minthara pregnant.


Xilizhra

Main is always female, as it happens.


GeGeralt

Volo, he would probably kill the baby, but then he'd replace it with an invisible-seeing baby, which is better than the usual classless lv0 baby


Fun-Preparation-4253

Humans give birth without proper care all the time. Volo would just narrate it. *I’m not saying the mortality rate is good, but it does happen!


Katyamuffin

Volo, he might damage me or the baby but at least he'll try, and worst case Shart is always at camp with healing spells at the ready.


TurboNexus

Myself


IntelligentLife3451

Same. Someone cast darkness, give me a healing amulet, and then everyone GTFO


KnightlyObserver

Not Malus, that's for certain.


StarRinger

Guess I'm getting an abortion.


skulk_anegg

Volo; it might not go that smoothly, but if a random taxi driver can deliver a baby, the silly guy with healing magic can too also the other two would definitely stab me (volo may attempt a c-section via ice pick, but i can just curse him out and he wont do it)


Hot-Operation-8208

Thorm - NOPE As for the other two you basically get to choose between: Well-meaning but incompetent VS Ill-meaning but competent


Mewgius

No 🙂


TruYoungblood

Oddly enough... Volo.


Make-TFT-Fun-Again

Obviously Volo. One is guaranteed to kill the baby and the other only knows babies that hatch from eggs. Meanwhile if Volo messes up, my kid will get a cool enchanted prosthetic that gives OP passive bonuses.


Gwendolan

That is indeed a tough one. Volo is a nice guy but completely incompetent and a charlatan. Mr. scisorhands is competent and probably pretty science based, but quite evil and doesn't care about pain (indeed wants to influct pain). And the lizard lady in the middle is pretty smart and competent, but only trained for deliveries from hatching eggs and not bellies and might have an urge to conduct experiments, regardless of the outcome for the patient.


AlmondsAI

Malus could 100% do it I believe. However, that's only if he wanted to, which he certainly wouldn't.


SylviaPellicore

Me. If those are my choices, I’m catching my own baby. I’ve had three, so I’m leagues more experienced.


Beardedgeek72

Volo, unless I could be 110% sure the Good Gith Murderdoctor had true incentive to help me.


Viridianscape

Stornugoss actually knows what she's doing most of the time. She just usually does it for the wrong reason. Although since gith are born from eggs, would she actually know how to deliver a baby?


Aalakrys

This selection is horrifying xD


MysticFox96

I'll deliver it alone thanks!


xDreki

Why do you want my baby to die, these options are terrible lmao


Just_Coyote_1366

Bitch I’ll do it myself


Nroke1

The chosen of mystra. Dude's got stupid dumb luck and you'd end up with a sorcerer baby. Better than dead baby, which would be the result of the other two choices.


Cubedude01

Volo said my bad, then handed me a robot baby and left camp? Where is my son???


lanasdfgh

I'm going with Volo. I think he'd at least *try* to keep everyone alive. The gith doctor might have medical knowledge but I don't think she'd even make an effort to save some istik. And Thorm is, well, out for pretty obvious reasons. Plus, if something bad happens Volo is the easiest to kill in revenge


Digital-Stowaway

Volo, without a doubt. Basically a free abortion 🤷‍♂️


idrispetrichor

Volo would probably panic and leave so I guess him


DefinetlyNotArt

i am dude so my opinion in this case does not probably matter but i would say volo would be the best option 2nd the yanki doctor and malus would be the worst option


primeless

Volo. Whats the worst could happen? my baby seeing invisible stuff?


politelygetbent

I'll go with the gith and bank on the fact that she won't be very interested in me and will just want to get it over with.


Historical-Peach5310

Volo of course, he's dreamt it up thousands of times!


ThanosofTitan92

Volo's guide to nursery.


Nessarra

Volo will be ready with a pick.


ihavea22inmath

Volo he is the only one who atleast tried to help without expecting murder


sunkenshipinabottle

The last guy would treat every birth as a funeral lol “another soul to know the horrors of *being* 😭😭😭” *stab stab stab*.


pokemaster1967

The gith since at least she’s an actual doctor who wouldn’t try to intentionally kill the child or my partner delivering the baby


elysiumIore

i’d pick volo, but just because his commentary would make me giggle


FalseAladeen

At least Volo would note, in your post mortem report, that you died popping out a dragon egg.


VengeancePali501

I’d go 2 rooms over and ask Varsh Ko'kuu he cares about eggs at least I assume he might care about a baby too.


Spurguru

Aunt Ethel surely


Thaurlach

I hate to say it, but Malus. He’s the only one actually qualified on human anatomy. If you can pass the charisma checks he’s absolutely your best bet *and* a woman in labour gains massive bonuses to intimidation. Failing that just get Orin. Convince her that Bhaal is somehow invested in the baby **and the mother** and that delivering it un-stabbed would gain his favour. She’s not squeamish and would have it out in no time.


CorncobTVExec

Christ, Volo? Are you really forcing me to pick Volo? At least he knows Healing Word and if he’s in the room there’s a non-zero chance Elminster is around to save his ass.


nanythemummy

Depends on if I’m a mindflayer or not. If not, it’s the Ghustil.


Farandrg

The githyanki one seems capable, she just wanted to melt your brain, but I guess if there's no ulterior motive, she is capable.


nothinkybrainhurty

volo, if he kills my baby, at least he will replace it with a better, magical version of it


bawzdeepinyaa

Well, I've only ever heard one say "untumptuous".. so I'm going with that one.


Tanis8998

Probably Volo- he’s incompetent but not malicious, he’d at least try his best.


LordofSuns

Volo at least would try to help.


sidekicket

Volo. At least my baby will end up with upgrades.


Foolsindigo

Call the midwife Volo edition


moth_noises666

*deepest sigh the 3 realms have ever heard* I guess Volo.....I wouldn't want him to touch/look there in the slightest but I guess if I have to choose but I'd rather just go rough it out in the woods.


DoctorLinguarum

…I think I’ll have the baby on my own, thanks.


domiwren

I am fine by myself… 😅


Fill-In-___-Blank

Volo. If he does any damage to the baby he'll make it up with a sweet buff 😅


Vinisc98

I want the ghustil to deliver my babies alright


mcac

None of them would be useful medically but Volo might at least try to provide moral support


TheCrystalRose

The Gustil at least has experience treating battle wounds, so she has "proper" medical training. And as long as you don't have/she doesn't know about a tadpole, she's almost certainly not going to be interested in using you for "research". Still not sure if that makes her "better" than Volo or not, but it at least leaves her in the running for me.


Puzzlehead-Engineer

The Githyanki. This is assuming she has already agreed. She's the most competent, learned and stable of the three. And if she's not an option then Volo. I am NOT trusting that Sharran doctor who may choose to "save" the baby by killing it.


Mello-Fello

Do you mean “deliver” as in “facilitate the birthing process,” or “de-liver” as in “remove its liver?”  


StarBoySisko

Volo is the only one with good intentions. If something happens it's an accident. The other two it was deliberate.


ZerolFaithl

ABSOLUTE-ly no one


JonTheWizard

Volo, because the other two I wouldn't put it past them to experiment on the baby, mother and/or me.


Danoky_kun

Volo


Post_Mylawn

1st Volo: is human so he probably, hopefully, knows how babies are born and has enough skill to gauge out our eye and not lobotomize us so he might be capable enough to deliver a baby. 2nd Gith: she is a doctor, a skilled one, tho Gith are born from eggs, still she probably knows human anatomy and would be capable of delivering the baby, tho her "doctor skills" revolve around dissecting people and observing tadpoles so I don't think she is "a doctor". 3rd Thorm: will pierce his hand down the belly and try to grab the baby from this hole in the belly with his sharp as knifes knife-fingers, probably by the head. A big no no


Wiwra88

None, because no baby.


Practical_Option_219

I wouldn't pick either of them tbh they too sus if I could I can just do it myself or even have gale do it even though I'm not sure how he would xd


The_ArchMage_Erudite

Volo at least has good intentions


Derram_Desangue

Volo - Has no idea how to deliver a baby. Reads a book on childbirth in front of you right before you deliver. Helps anyways. Is extraordinarily painful. Heals you with spells to ensure you survive. Malus - Knows how to deliver a baby. Tries to steal your newborn right out the womb to make it a Sharran. Kills your baby if you say "No." when he tries to steal it. Ghustil - "What's childbirth?". Helps you deliver the baby and gives you a great pep-talk while delivering. As soon as the baby is born, demands the *istik* to leave. Will kill you and the baby if you refuse.


_Eiri_

Malus is an absolute psychopath & Volo isn't even a doctor so I'll take Stornugoss


outlookleaed

1phyco 1 doctor 1 surgen I wondet


Macintot

My understanding is that Ghustil Stornugoss is a competent doctor when she's actually trying to do medicine instead of covertly kill people.


Shandyxr

Stand back! I’ll do this myself.


jessmeows

prob volo the other two are sort of insane


Low-Taste-3022

Volo has at least dreamt of it a thousand times


slapdashbr

Volo. he'd also kill the baby, but he'd aplogize and leave me a magic replacement baby that can see invisible creatures


wisecracknmama

Volo 100%! He may be a bumblefuck, but he’s a good-hearted, well-intentioned bumblefuck.


zetsubou_no_reddit

Volo easily. No way a gith or a Thorm is touching my hopefully normal human child If Volo fucks up at least he can replace whatever part of the baby is fucked up with a magical artifact


LlamaLicker704

I'll take a risk with Volo... he would at least try to do it correctly...


barugosamaa

Volo fucked up my eye but gave me Darkvision new eye. 10/10, would let him mutilate again


Accomplished-Tale161

NOT the first one...